Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The transnational use of works protected by copyright in the digital environment has intensified multi-jurisdictional disputes and raised unique questions about applicable law. In China, Article 50 of the Act on the Application of Laws over Foreign-related Civil Relationships adopts the law of the place for which protection is claimed (lex loci protectionis) as the governing choice of law rule in foreign-related copyright infringement disputes. However, the interpretation of lex loci protectionis has long remained uncertain. Neither legislation nor existing scholarship has provided clear guidance for identifying the place for which protection is claimed. To examine how Chinese courts apply the choice of law rule in practice, this article conducts an empirical study of 2198 judicial decisions, focusing on the consistency of judicial reasoning. The findings suggest that Chinese law was applied in every case reviewed. However, the courts adopted inconsistent approaches in their choice of law reasoning. More importantly, the study reveals that the overwhelming majority of disputes did not involve genuine conflicts over the applicable law. As a result, courts were rarely required to resolve a contested choice between potentially applicable laws. The article argues that the uniform application of Chinese law should not be taken as evidence of a judicial preference for domestic law. The key explanation lies in the absence of genuine choice of law conflicts in judicial practice. The findings also highlight the need for Chinese courts to develop a more consistent interpretation of lex loci protectionis to enhance legal certainty in future disputes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yutong HOU (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: