Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The ‘One Substance, One Assessment’ (OSOA) approach, introduced in the EU’s Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability in 2020, aims to achieve more consistent chemical risk assessments by enabling access, sharing and reuse of information on chemicals. While regulatory frameworks have been designed for different purposes, the OSOA introduces a new vision of consistent risk assessments across sectoral frameworks. However, the information available for sharing will to a large degree depend on what is required under each applicable regulatory framework. For the OSOA to achieve consistent risk assessments across frameworks, comparable hazard information should reasonably be available, regardless of which regulatory framework the assessment is conducted under. This raises the question of whether the current system can support such a vision, or whether revisions to information requirements are needed. To establish a minimum baseline for consistency, one approach proposed in this study could be to focus on the most harmful properties as defined by the Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability. To test this, this study investigated whether and under what criteria comparable information, defined as ‘baseline information requirements’, for the most harmful human health endpoints is required across eight regulatory frameworks. The results show that across all eight frameworks and all investigated endpoints, the criteria for when information on these endpoints is required differ considerably. None of the investigated endpoints required comparable information consistently across all eight frameworks, with information requirements commonly being conditional based on exposure or effects-driven criteria. These findings suggest that even where comparable hazard information is required, differences in when that information is required across frameworks could hinder more consistent hazard assessments as envisioned by the OSOA. Based on these findings, we suggest that rather than revising each regulatory framework individually, addressing these differences through an overarching framework could establish a minimum baseline for consistency across all substances. This would strengthen the OSOA by ensuring that a comparable baseline of information exists for assessments, while still allowing each framework to require additional information according to their own scope and protection goals.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Andreassen et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: