Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Despite growing interest in “news deserts” across Europe, the cartographic practices used to visualise local journalism remain critically under-examined. Maps are a powerful tool for making the spatial patterns of news provision visible and comparable across regions. However, post-critical cartography shows that maps encode power geometries, not neutral representations. Building on this tradition and neopragmatist approaches, this paper presents a multi-level framework for analysing how “news desert” maps construct spatial knowledge. The framework distinguishes between cartosyntactics (technical and design choices), cartosemantics (meanings, narratives and classifications) and cartopragmatics (positionality, uses and potential impacts), as well as the broader structural and historical contexts. Through three case studies — Local Media for Democracy (EU), Wüstenradar (Germany) and Mapping Local News Provisions and Reach in England (UK) — the analytical lens is tested to examine how news desert maps operate through technical and design choices, narrative and classification frames, and the entangled uses, and positionalities of mapmakers. This framework can be applied to maps used in journalism studies and in journalism practice. It aims to foster reflexive, context-sensitive and transparent mapping practices that move beyond binary deficit frames. Instead, it foregrounds the politics of visibility that structure contemporary media ecologies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Atteneder et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: