Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This preprint asks whether the pair-ordering temperature of a Holstein or bond-SSH electron-phonon model can be bounded at a temperature scale proportional to the phonon frequency, uniformly in that frequency and at fixed hopping and coupling. That linear step remains open, and the preprint does not close it. It records three exact obstructions that identify which proof methods cannot reach it, together with one case where a frequency-uniform ceiling does survive. First, for the Holstein model with arbitrary real static site fields, the exact first coefficient of the local dynamic cumulant, computed with the dynamic Gaussian already integrated out, is at least U Omega2/(1200 tau3) on an open three-site path for 0 < Omega <= tau <= t/4, and at least U Omega2/(2400 tau3) on every square torus of side at least four with a finite static barrier. At tau = C Omega this diverges as Omega decreases to zero, so no expansion whose uniform local activity must dominate it can stay small. Second, a strictly positive single-impurity determinant does not bound the impurity propagator: on a two-slice history the fermion determinant exceeds one, all monodromy eigenvalues are positive, and the conditional Green function grows as B2/(2v2); an interval-certified fixture at B = 6, v = 1/2 gives det(1+U) > 15 and |G(1,0)00| > 52.89. Third, for the pure bond-SSH model with vanishing effective attraction the high-temperature regime is closed: for beta|t| + beta Gb <= 2-10 the pair correlator is at most (341/103)(32/341)d, uniformly in frequency, chemical potential and density, so kBTpair <= 1024(|t|+Gb), and three further proof routes are obstructed by exact identities. The bounds are on the model quantities Tpair and Tlin. Nothing here is a bound on a measured transition temperature, and no materials claim is made. Every statement is labelled in the accompanying claim map as PROVED (the analytic argument), CERTIFIED (exact-rational or outward-rounded interval arithmetic, replayed in the supplement with an independent implementation and guarded mutants) or NUMERICAL (finite-matrix and floating-point sanity checks that are not part of any proof). The replays do not formalize the analytic arguments. AI agents generated the proofs, code and drafts under D. Rens' direction, and separate AI agents carried out the independent reviews. This preprint has not been peer reviewed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Davis Rens (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: