Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
OBJECTIVE: To conduct a cross-country assessment of five nutrient profile models (NPM) under consideration in Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria, Tanzania and South Africa by evaluating their feasibility, regulatory coverage and alignment. DESIGN: We applied five NPM to assess data availability, exemption rates and compliance rates for each NPM and performed pairwise correlations to measure alignment. SETTING: Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria, Tanzania, South Africa. PARTICIPANTS: 28 609 packaged food product records reflecting items available in 2020-2023. RESULTS: Data availability varied by nutrient. While nutrients like energy and sodium were commonly reported, critical data like added sugar and fibre were frequently missing, requiring extensive imputation, impacting feasibility. Nutri-Score, which demands the most comprehensive data, had the lowest proportion of usable records (86 %) compared to the Pan-American Health Organization model (PAHO) (98 %) and the NPM proposed in South Africa's front-of-package labelling regulation (SA FOPL) (95 %). The SA FOPL and PAHO models demonstrated high feasibility and low implementation burden, exempting a considerable percentage of products (16-18 %). Conversely, the NPM for the WHO African Region (AFRO) and Kenyan models exempted very few products (<5 %) and resulted in the highest non-compliance. Nutri-Score showed the weakest correlation with all other models. CONCLUSIONS: NPM are crucial for food policies, but their successful implementation in an African context requires balancing the best available evidence with feasibility. The SA FOPL and PAHO models emerge as more implementable given current data and resource constraints, while the AFRO and Kenyan models exempt few products and carry higher burdens. NPM selection should consider available evidence, specific policy goals, regulatory capacity, data infrastructure and context-specific adaptations for successful policy implementation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ng et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: