Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The interpretation of Mandarin object nouns (e.g. qiu “ball”) is central to the count-mass debate over whether countability is lexically specified (semantic account) or syntactically constructed (syntactic account). Previous forced-choice Quantity Judgment Task (QJT) studies reported only count interpretations, supporting the semantic account. Challenging this generalization, we employed the Truth Value Judgment Task (TVJT) to test Mandarin-speaking children and adults. Experiment 1 used a simplified TVJT with neutral contexts to enable direct comparison with prior QJT studies. While the QJT replicated count-only results, the TVJT revealed that children accessed both count and mass interpretations, exposing the QJT as measuring preference, not grammatical availability. Adults maintained count interpretations, suggesting they require stronger contextual support. Experiment 2 employed a more standardized TVJT with felicitous contexts, manipulating both context and linguistic conditions. Bare nouns showed systematic contextual flexibility: both children and adults interpreted them as mass in amount-oriented contexts but as count in individual-oriented contexts. Classifier-noun phrases, however, yielded exclusive count interpretations across both contexts, demonstrating that the individual classifier (ge) forces count interpretations regardless of context. Together, our findings overturn earlier QJT-based evidence, showing that bare nouns are underspecified and that classifier syntax serves as the decisive grammatical marker for countability. The results provide robust support for the syntactic account and underscore how methodological choice shapes theoretical positions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Huang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: