Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Although recent studies have established a melt–fluid evolutionary framework for REE mineralization in carbonatitic systems, the role of sodium (Na), a principal alkali component, in fluid saturation, REE partitioning between melt and fluid, and REE mineral crystallization remains incompletely constrained. To evaluate the role of Na during REE mineralization, we conducted high-pressure, high-temperature experiments at 550–650 °C and 100 MPa, investigating the crystallization of REE minerals and fluid saturation in a simplified CaCO 3 -Na 2 CO 3 -LaF 3 system containing 10 or 20 wt% bulk Na 2 CO 3 , with corresponding CaCO 3 contents of 70 or 60 wt% at a fixed LaF 3 content of 20 wt%. Experiments were run either as anhydrous compositions or fluid-bearing with the addition of pure H 2 O, a 3.3 mol L −1 NaCl aqueous solution, or a 1.7 mol L −1 Na 2 SO 4 aqueous solution. Run products contained calcite and quenched carbonatitic melt, together with variable assemblages of bastnäsite, carbocernaite, and a Ca–F phase. Vapor cavities in fluid-bearing runs are interpreted as evidence of a separate fluid phase. Comparative experiments showed that, at a given temperature, increasing the bulk Na 2 CO 3 content from 10 to 20 wt% results in increasing carbonatitic melt fraction. The higher bulk Na 2 CO 3 content is also associated with greater inferred H 2 O retention in the carbonatitic melt. In fluid-bearing experiments, REE minerals crystallized within the quenched carbonatitic melt rather than within vapor cavities. Fluid–melt partition coefficients calculated from mass balance ranged from 0.05 to 0.13 for La and 0.09 to 0.31 for F. Chlorine- and sulfur-bearing components introduced through the addition of fluids were also detected in the quenched carbonatitic melt. These results show that REE are preferentially retained in the melt and that REE minerals crystallize primarily within the carbonatitic melt during melt–fluid coexistence. In bastnäsite-bearing experiments, carbonatitic melts with higher Na 2 O contents also contained higher La 2 O 3 concentrations, suggesting that higher Na may enhance the capacity of carbonatitic melts to retain dissolved REE during REE mineral crystallization. The species of crystallizing REE minerals in the carbonatitic melts varied with bulk Na 2 CO 3 content and temperature. In the high-Na system (20 wt% bulk Na 2 CO 3 ), carbocernaite was dominant (12.9 vol%) at 550 °C, whereas only minor bastnäsite crystallized (2.9 vol%) at 600 °C. In the low-Na system (10 wt% bulk Na 2 CO 3 ), bastnäsite crystallized from 550 to 650 °C (4.8–9.9 vol%). These relations suggest that higher Na availability favors alkali–REE carbonate crystallization, whereas lower Na availability favors bastnäsite crystallization in carbonatitic systems. Together, these findings indicate that primary REE mineralization remains melt-dominated during melt–fluid coexistence rather than shifting toward hydrothermal control. Within this melt-dominated framework, Na influences melt persistence, fluid saturation, REE retention in carbonatitic melts, and the crystallization of REE minerals during melt–fluid evolution in carbonatitic systems
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ma et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: