The observed dipole in extragalactic source number counts is approximately twice as large as the kinematic expectation derived from the CMB rest frame, a discrepancy that has persisted across radio, infrared, and mid-infrared catalogues and remained contested despite extensive investigation of local structure, masking, and survey-systematic effects. Most discussions treat the excess as evidence for an unknown source-side effect, a violation of the cosmological principle, or a statistical fluctuation. Here, we explore an observer-relative alternative motivated by Wheeler's participatory view of measurement. Building on companion analyses in which the observer's causal diamond was modelled as an information aperture (isotropic for the low-power anomaly, quadrupolar for the Axis of Evil) we extend the participatory-horizon framework to the dipolar (L = 1) sector of the recording kernel. In the additive formulation, the kernel's first Legendre mode couples to the dominant source-count monopole via Gaunt integrals, injecting a constant excess D_ = A into the observed dipole parallel to the observer's velocity, where A is an aperture amplification factor. Applied to the CatWISE2020 photometric quasar catalogue (\, 1. 36 million sources over \, 47\% of the sky), the pipeline yields A = 5. 3 1. 3 at the fiducial threshold (W1 16. 4\, mag), a 4. 0 excess above the kinematic-only model. The corresponding dipole gain is G = D_ / D₊₈₍ = 1. 86 0. 21; within the additive framework the full -projected excess is accounted for, reducing the \, 4 tension along the velocity axis to a single fitted parameter. A cumulative magnitude-threshold scan finds A stable over the high-purity range (W1 16. 1), with a mean of \, 6. 7, declining only where catalogue contamination is expected to dominate the sample; in contrast to the monotonic dilution predicted by local-structure models. A 30-configuration robustness grid confirms insensitivity to neighbour-buffer depth and ecliptic model, with the Galactic latitude cut as the dominant systematic. The transverse component D_ is small at bright thresholds and grows with catalogue depth, compatible with an on-axis additive excess from an axisymmetric kernel and a separate threshold-dependent contaminant. The framework makes a parameter-free cross-survey prediction that the absolute excess D_ should be common to all source populations, so that surveys with different Ellis--Baldwin prefactors should exhibit predictably different fractional excesses. Spectroscopic redshift slices from DESI and forthcoming surveys can test this directly, since a constant A across redshift bins would be difficult to explain by any source-side mechanism. Together with the companion analyses of the CMB power deficit (L=0) and the Axis-of-Evil alignment (L=2), these results extend the participatory recording kernel to a third anomaly channel, the source-count dipole tension, conventionally discussed outside the CMB large-angle literature. A single kernel W () =1+₁ P₁ () +₂ P₂ (), applied to a standard CDM background, can feasibly accommodate all three anomalies through successive Legendre sectors; several significant open problems are discussed.
Building similarity graph...
Analyzing shared references across papers
Loading...
Gregory O'Grady
University of Auckland
Building similarity graph...
Analyzing shared references across papers
Loading...
Gregory O'Grady (Mon,) studied this question.
www.synapsesocial.com/papers/6a02c364ce8c8c81e9640af8 — DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20114712