Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Literature review highlights ecological impacts of CIPP and open-trench methods, suggesting SimaPro as an evaluation tool.
An ecological impact assessment (EIA) involves the evaluation of information about pipe raw materials, processes, and product manufacturing to obtain the associated emissions and ecological impacts. Open-Trench (OT) pipeline replacement involves digging a trench along the length of the proposed pipeline, placing the pipe in the trench on suitable bedding materials, and then embedding and backfilling. The trenchless cured-in-place pipe (CIPP) method involves a liquid thermoset resin-saturated material that is inserted into the existing pipeline by hydrostatic or air inversion or by mechanically pulling in and inflating. The liner material is cured in place using hot water or steam or light cured using ultraviolet light, resulting in the CIPP product. The objectives of this paper are (1) to present a literature review on the progress acquired over the years in understanding the ecological impacts from the CIPP and OT methods, (2) to present a framework for the evaluation of the ecological impacts using SimaPro software, and (3) to identify the factors that influence the environment for the CIPP and OT methods. A total of 150 published papers were identified that reported the ecological impacts of the CIPP and OT methods over a period from 1990 through 2025. The literature review suggests that the material production phase consumes a large amount of energy and is a major contributor to ecological impacts. Higher ecological impacts from the OT method are a result of longer project durations and more equipment requirements compared to the CIPP. The liner, felt, and resin influenced the environment the most for CIPP as compared to the OT method, where the power consumption of construction equipment and the pipe material had the greatest ecological impacts. It can be concluded that the comparison of the ecological impacts of pipeline renewal and replacement is an important element when considering sustainable underground infrastructure planning, design, and development.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Karkhanis et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: