Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article reveals how penance influenced political compromise in the Renaissance papal court, emphasizing clemency and contrition as key factors.
This article addresses the culture of penance that pervaded the Renaissance papal court and particularly its relationship to political compromise in the form of acts of clemency and absolution. In doing so, this article illuminates the lasting influence of penitential thought in gesture and writing and its ready availability to inspire accounts of crucial political events that transpired during the papacy's most unruly periods. The pontificates of Pius II and Clement VII were noteworthy for their widespread rebellion against papal authority and the difficulties a pope could face when the Papal States' most powerful subjects aligned themselves with international coalitions against whom the papacy waged war. Yet it was precisely in moments of crisis that penitential thought acquired its relevancy, and the fullness of meaning attached to penitential acts was able to manifest itself. A plethora of penitential acts or their records are available, but this article focuses on tears specifically, as signifiers of true contrition and incontrovertible admission of having sinned. Ascribing tears to opponents thus served as a literary tool to bolster papal ideology, for rebellion was framed as sin, while another interpretation might be that shows of contrition paved the way for political compromise.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Loek Luiten (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: