State-of-the-art comparisons of ab initio calculations of density virial coefficients for helium-4 with measurements

The virial coefficients of cryogenic gases, especially helium-4 and helium-3, are playing an ever more critical role in the establishment of primary reference standards for temperature after the redefinition of the kelvin in the SI. Thus, the reliability of the values and uncertainties of these coefficients, especially those of the second, third, even fourth density virial coefficients (B, C and D), has become more significant. To check the accuracy of these coefficients for helium-4 from ab initio calculations, the refractive-index gas thermometry (RIGT) method was developed, allowing for the simultaneous determination of thermodynamic temperatures and density virial coefficients. Using this technique, highly accurate experimental values of B, C and D for helium-4, as well as TT90 values, were obtained for the range 5 K to 25 K. Direct comparisons with the ab initio calculation density virial coefficients for helium-4 were conducted, revealing excellent agreement. Furthermore, good agreements of thermodynamic temperatures T between absolute RIGT and our previous single pressure RIGT (Metrologia 58 (2021) 059501) were achieved at temperatures from 5 K to 25 K, with differences within each standard uncertainty. This further strengthens our confidence in the comparisons made in this work. It is foreseeable that the rigorously verified ab initio calculations of density virial coefficients for helium-4 will continue to be used to improve the measurement accuracy of primary reference standards for temperature and pressure, based on helium-4.