Synthesis, Properties, and Electrochemical Proton Reduction of a Homoleptic Tetrathiolato Ni-Site Model of [NiFe]-Hydrogenase

[NiFe]-hydrogenase enzymes process H2 at a nonplanar tetracysteinato-Ni site, the sole participator in proton binding/redox chemistry during turnover. With the objective of assessing whether a simple tetrahedral/tetrathiolato-Ni2+ core could promote H2 evolution reaction (HER), we synthesized (Et4N)2[Ni(S-p-CF3-Ph)4] (1) employing para-trifluoromethylbenzenethiolate (-S-p-CF3-Ph) as a Ni-site analog of [NiFe]-hydrogenase. Spectroscopic measurements and X-ray crystallography confirm the distorted tetrahedral geometry of 1. Dissolution of 1 results in partial thiolate dissociation and formation of S,S-bridged complexes such as (Et4N)2[Ni2(S-p-CF3-Ph)6] (3) among other ill-defined species. Dissociation is further accelerated in the presence of Brønsted acids, complicating the assessment of 1 for proton reduction. However, this dissociation/proton instability is suppressed in the presence of additional thiolate ligand to ensure tetrahedral/tetrathiolato 1 persists in solution. Electrochemical HER activity was evaluated by monitoring the current response of an MeCN solution of 1/excess thiolate after sequential titration with a weak Brønsted acid (acetic acid). The results suggest that 1 is a modest electrocatalyst for the HER with a turnover frequency of 14.5 ± 3.6 s-1 and an overpotential of 0.72 ± 0.02 V. Control experiments and supplementary DFT computations indicate that 1, or a species derived from 1, is responsible for the HER and suggest an ECCE-type mechanism.