Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Examination reveals the pitfalls of ADP methods for undrained stability in natural slopes, suggesting crucial adjustments.
Low plastic soft clays are known to exhibit effect of anisotropy, with significant variations of undrained shear strength dependent on direction of loading. The peak undrained shear strengths obtained in active (A), direct simple shear (D) and passive (P) modes of loading varies significantly. It is essential to capture this shear strength anisotropy for correct modelling of undrained problems. There exist numerical tools based on total stress ADP methods where different “default” factors are assigned for each mode of failure to accommodate the strength anisotropy. These methods are developed with an assumption of an initially flat terrain where the initial maximum principal stress direction is vertical throughout the boundary problem. A relevant application of these methods includes short-term stability evaluations of cuts and fillings from initially flat terrain. In natural slopes, however, the direction of the in-situ principal stress is essentially inclined; thus, contrary to the fundamental assumption of current ADP method. Despite this, ADP analyses are routinely performed for the undrained stability assessment of natural slopes in the current Norwegian practice. Typically, this will result in lower shear strength for direct shear and passive mode compared to what can be obtained from testing under the relevant stress conditions. Using existing ADP tools, this work illustrates pitfalls of current ADP method for natural slopes stability. This is supplemented experimentally where inclined samples were extracted from a slope in accordance with the initial principal stress direction. The results of laboratory tests on these samples showed significant differences in the shear strength anisotropy comparted to the current practice of taking vertical samples from slopes. It is crucial that the practice recognizes that initial effective stress states and stress orientations are essential even for undrained analyses.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Grimstad et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: