Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Undrained stability assessments show critical safety factors differ between drained and undrained methods, suggesting flaws in common practices.
Natural slopes are formed by geological processes (like sedimentation, gravitational compression/creep, uplift, landslides and erosion) and are characterized by steady-state pore water pressure conditions. Over time, these processes create shear strength variations depending on the loading direction (strength anisotropy) within slopes. In Norway, stability of natural slope is assessed using the so-called “drained” and “undrained“ methods, often producing significantly different safety factors. Undrained assessments typically indicate unsafe conditions (safety factors obtained by the limit equilibrium methods are close to or even below one), while drained evaluations suggest sufficient stability without additional safety measures. Notably, the “undrained” assessment does not consider the generation of excess pore water pressure as a cause of instability, despite the term “undrained”. Moreover, undrained shear strength values are typically estimated from lab or field tests under specific shearing modes, which may not fully represent the varying shearing modes within slopes. To account for the effects of geological history, such as the development of over-consolidation and anisotropy through the slope formation history of stress and deformation, a viscoplastic constitutive model was developed within the framework of critical state soil mechanics. The model is implemented in the finite element code PLAXIS and includes six dimensionless parameters calibrated for Onsøy clay in Norway. A series of undrained effective stress-based stability analyses on hypothetical slopes with different geometry were conducted to explore the impact of the formation history on the undrained safety factor. Considering the long-standing history of natural slopes, the undrained safety factor was evaluated by gradually increasing the gravitational loading until failure, driven by the generation of excess pore water pressure along the already developed mechanisms within slopes. The results indicate that, for natural slopes, drained stability is generally more critical than undrained stability—a conclusion that contrasts with common practice in Norway, where undrained stability is often perceived as more critical.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dadras-Ajirlou et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: