Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Analysis reveals disparities in training programs for international medical graduates, suggesting potential impacts on patient care.
It is recognised that there is a shortage of surgical specialists in rural and regional areas in Australia, and that the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (RACS) and other organisations have been unable to satisfactorily remedy this situation over many years. To address this, the National Cabinet commissioned and endorsed the Kruk Report [1], which evaluated the regulatory settings for overseas-trained health professionals. From this report, the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (Ahpra) recently announced an expedited pathway for specialist international medical graduates (SIMG's) from the United Kingdom (UK) [2] (and also Ireland) to gain specialist recognition in Australia. The specialties currently include Anaesthesia, Obstetrics and Gynaecology, General Practice and Psychiatry, with surgical specialities soon to be introduced. Currently, the assessment of comparability of SIMG's is determined by specialist surgical colleges. However, expedited pathways allow SIMG's on the National Specialist Register in those countries to apply directly to Ahpra for specialist registration in Australia. Ahpra have stated that the expedited pathway 'is designed to remove unnecessary regulatory barriers and increase the number of SIMGs seeing patients in Australia, while maintaining high standards' [2]. However, for this to be successfully achieved, training programs and accreditation standards across regions must align and be comparable. A close inspection of the training programs and standards reveal that this supposition is misleading and instituting 'expedited pathways risk creating a two-tier[ed] surgical workforce, undermining the rigorous training and accreditation processes currently in place' [3] and 'potentially lowering the standard of care for patients' [3]. The Urological Society of Australia and New Zealand (USANZ) acts as an agent of RACS to administer the Surgical Education and Training Program (SET) in Urology, which is accredited by the Australian Medical Council (AMC) to conduct surgical training [4]. 'The aim of the training program remains the development of a proficient general urologist; and procedures which are integral to the skillset of such have therefore been retained as "core," with competence to be assessed and achieved' [5]. An updated curriculum developed in 2021 has retained core operating skills to prevent any reliance on overseas fellowships or extra training requirements for trainees to develop necessary operating skills. Indeed, the graduate outcomes for the SET Program in Urology include the ability for all newly graduated urologists to independently 'perform surgical procedures to treat urological conditions, including but not limited to nephrectomy, total prostatectomy, cystectomy with urinary diversion, inguinal-scrotal procedures, endourology and percutaneous nephrolithotomy' [6]. The British Association of Urological Surgeons (BAUS), the training body for UK urologists, also updated their curriculum in 2021 [7]. There were concerns that their 'previous curriculum failed to equip trainees with those skills needed to deliver an unselected take in adult and paediatric emergency urology and to support colleagues from other specialities in the secondary care setting' [7] and prepared trainees with 'the bare minimum for a general urologist' [8]. The updated UK training program has adapted with a more individualised approach, with varying competency levels to be achieved for different procedures for graduating urologists. Trainees must select a special interest (SI) area, with higher thresholds for competence in specific procedural skills to successfully complete the training program. These SI areas include Endo-urology; Andrology and Infertility; Female, Functional and Reconstructive Urology; Advanced General Urology and Urological Oncology Surgery [7]. The list of index procedures, common to all trainees which are of 'significant importance for patient safety and to demonstrate a safe breadth of practice' include: urodynamics, prostate biopsy, transurethral resection of prostate and bladder tumour, penoscrotal procedures (including orchidopexy) and ureteroscopy and laser lithotripsy [7]. Whilst a trainee who has completed Oncology SI will be required to achieve Level 3 competency (can do whole procedure but needs assistance) in laparoscopic nephrectomy, the trainee who chooses to do another SI area (e.g., Endo-urology) will be expected to achieve Level 2 competency (can do with assistance) in laparoscopic nephrectomy [7]. This contrasts with the USANZ training program where all trainees must demonstrate competence in completion of laparoscopic nephrectomy independently prior to the completion of training. A review of UK logbook data in 2017 found that 'the majority [of trainees] having been demonstrated to be below expectations in a large number of domains. Despite this failure to achieve the requirements, no trainees to date have been denied the award of CCT [Certificate of Completion of Training] as a result' [9]. The UK system protects trainees against any risks that a lack of training may entail and their curriculum states: 'In the case of technical skills, it is anticipated that attaining operative skills in all procedures may not be possible. It is expected that at least 80% of the procedural competencies would be achieved by CCT in their special interest module(s)'. These issues highlight significant concerns with the comparability of the UK training program to our own. Due to our geography and population distribution, centralised care, which involves the reorganisation of healthcare services into fewer specialised units, is not a feature of the Australian healthcare system. Although a degree of sub-specialisation exists beyond training, urological care relies on well-trained surgeons with proficiency in general urology. With the arrival of surgeons undertaking an expedited pathway, we place the onus on individual SIMG's to be aware that their skill set may substantially differ from their Australian counterparts. Careful credentialing processes will be vital when surgeons emerge from the expedited pathway. Hospitals and networks will need to be aware of likely limitations in these surgeons' scope of practice. Core credentialing pathways in hospitals commonly include laparoscopic/open abdominal and pelvic surgical proficiency as such skills are needed for the provision of emergency urological care. The ability of a surgeon who has completed an expedited pathway to competently manage emergency cases (e.g., a UK-trained urologist whose SI was andrology and infertility needing to perform an emergency nephrectomy), especially in regional or rural setting, is of concern given the knowledge we have regarding the limitations of their training. This concern is also echoed by Lee et al. [9] in the ability of graduating BAUS urologists to cope with emergency work in general district hospitals in the UK, in light of the reduction in training requirements stating 'how we overcome this is not clear'. RACS must actively pursue mechanisms for ensuring that patients who live outside metropolitan areas have access to local surgical care. There needs to be greater advocacy for funding further surgical training positions in teaching hospitals, increasing efforts to harness the underutilised training opportunities that exist in the private sector, and expanding the SET program, rather than relying on a quick 'imported' fix. The introduction of surgeons, accredited via the expedited pathway into the Australian healthcare system, should be approached with great caution. RACS has raised a number of concerns regarding this proposal, including inadequate supervision, lack of rural support, and the undermining of surgical standards [3]. Registration of overseas-trained surgeons should continue to be assessed on an individual basis to prevent the introduction of a two-tiered surgical system and to safeguard what should be every surgeon's primary focus—optimal patient care. Open access publishing facilitated by Deakin University, as part of the Wiley - Deakin University agreement via the Council of Australian University Librarians. The authors have nothing to report. The authors declare no conflicts of interest. Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
McLeod et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: