Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Descriptive analysis evaluates conflicts in head of state immunity and individual criminal responsibility, highlighting implications for international justice.
Purpose: Evaluate the relevance of the Law of Head of State Immunity against the principle of individual criminal responsibility.Methodology: This descriptive and analytical discourse made constructive usage of both primary and secondary data. Primary data entailed basic documents viz; Constitutions, statutes, treaties as well the relevant resolutions by the United Nation. Secondary data comprised majorly of publications by most highly qualified publicists in the nature of Journals and ArticlesResults: In the light of the foregoing research, it is true to assert that the in as far as the ICC jurisdiction is concerned; there exists a conflict between the principle of individual immunity and that of executive immunity. This conflict is resolved by the operation of a jus cogens principle of ICR with the effect of nullifying a mere international customary rule of jurisdictional immunities. Further, a party to the Rome Statute is bound by its provision among which is article 25 and 27 of the former. Consent to be bound by article 25 and 27 of the Rome Statute is an equivalence of a waiver of such immunities.Unique contribution to theory, practice and policy: The ultimate object to resolution of the conflict between the two doctrines is this. That the "˜most serious crimes of concern to the international community of states must not go unpunished.' Further that the objects and purpose of international criminal justice not to be defeated. The Judgement of the International Military Tribunals, Trials of the Major War Criminals case held that sole rationale of international criminal law regime is to attribute criminal liability to individuals without exception to their official capacity and most importantly to defeat the defence of official capacity or act of state. The position is further buttressed by an internal provision of fundamental importance, article 143 (4) of the Constitution of Kenya. This expressly waives the principle of executive immunity attached to the president for crimes committed within the jurisdiction of the ICC. Thus if this object must be met, the principle of executive immunity must not bar the principle of individual criminal responsibility.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nyanje et al. (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: