Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Quasi-experimental study compares heart rate and perceived fatigue in females during activities, suggesting unique effects of physical and brain exertion.
Background and Aims Fatigue resulting from physical and cognitive activities is one of the fundamental challenges in sports sciences and neurosciences, which can affect an individual’s physical and psychological performance. The present study aims to compare the effects of physical activity and brain activity until exhaustion on heart rate (objective physiological response) and perceived exertion of fatigue (subjective response) in females. Methods This is a quasi-experimental study on 20 female students aged 25-30 from Alzahra University, Tehran, Iran, who were selected using a purposive sampling method. They were divided into two groups: brain activity (n=10) and physical activity (n=10). The physical activity group performed the plank exercise for 15 minutes or more until reaching fatigue, while the brain activity group performed the Stroop task for 45 minutes. Borg’s Rating of Perceived Exertion Scale, Falstein et al.’s 10-item fatigue assessment scale, and a Polar heart rate monitor were used to collect data. Perceived exertion of physical and mental fatigue, and heart rate in each group were recorded before the activity, 5 and 10 minutes during the activity, immediately after, and five minutes after the end of the activity. Results The results of repeated measures analysis of variance showed that the heart rate and perceived exertion of physical and mental fatigue in both groups increased with increasing duration of physical or mental exercises. The mean heart rate and perceived exertion of physical fatigue were significantly higher in the physical activity group than in the brain activity group in the fifth and tenth minutes during the activity, immediately after the end of the activity, and five minutes after the activity (P=0.001). The mean perceived exertion of mental fatigue was higher in the brain activity group than in the physical activity group in the fifth and tenth minutes during the activity, immediately after the end of the activity, and five minutes after the activity (P=0.001). Conclusion Physical activity until exhaustion mainly increases the physiological load (heart rate) of females, while brain activity until exhaustion increases their cognitive load (perceived exertion of mental fatigue). These results can provide a scientific basis for optimizing training programs for women by balancing between physical and mental loads. Designing effective exercise protocols for women requires simultaneous attention to physical and mental dimensions of fatigue. This integrated approach not only prevents the occurrence of premature exhaustion but also significantly reduces the risk of exercise-induced injuries.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mousavian et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: