Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Consonance and dissonance generally have positive and negative associations, respectively, in Western tonal music. A negatively associated event is known to enhance the listener’s positive appreciation of the following event, and this is referred to as the contrast effect. The question then is: does dissonance enhance the pleasantness of the following consonance due to the ensuing contrast? This idea was tested by employing short chord sequences ending with V-I as stimuli. The dissonance level of the penultimate chord V was manipulated by varying both its acoustic roughness and cultural familiarity, and 49 participants rated the pleasantness of the final chord I. We hypothesized that the final chord I would be more pleasant when the penultimate chord V was more dissonant. However, the results showed the opposite: greater dissonance in the penultimate chord V led to lower pleasantness ratings for the following final chord I. It could be that a greater dissonance in the penultimate chord V makes it less tonally related to the final chord I, and that its dissonance may have violated listeners’ tonal expectations. Rather than demonstrating the contrast effect, this result demonstrates dissonance’s strong connotation with unpleasantness and its influence on the pleasantness of the following consonance.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arthurs et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: