Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The article examines the applicability of the basic postulates of the classical understanding of the principle of separation of powers at the present stage of development of society and the state. The author concludes that the prevention of the usurpation of power as the main goal of the separation of powers is largely due not so much to the formally fixed recognition of this principle or the indication in the constitutional act of the existence of branches of government, but rather to the constitutional legal consciousness of society. The triad of branches of government proposed within the framework of the classical understanding of this principle does not correspond to the current trend of allocating functional branches of government. With a narrow interpretation of the classical approach, the functional branches of government can be removed from the system of checks and balances, which leads to the risk of inefficiency of the bodies of the functional branches of government. The reference to the separation of powers due to different social bases should also be questioned in connection with the emergence of non-hereditary functional branches of government and a significant change in the social structure. It is necessary to recognize the functional branches of government as element of separation of powers and adapt to them the classical understanding of the theory of separation of powers, since the specifics of the organs of the functional branches of government do not allow them to usurp power and cannot be fully integrated into the classical system of separation of powers. An assessment of the independence of such bodies and the possibility of monitoring their activities by other authorities is seen as a possible theoretical and doctrinal solution.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nikita A. Tikhanov (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: