Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Once a lodestar of the international Left, the South African labor movement has beenin a long downward spiral. For well over a decade membership rolls have been shrinking,organization has been fracturing and corruption festering. This article traces the decline tolabor’s failure to transform the post-Apartheid social structure. Propelled by the momentumof the victorious liberation struggle, the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU)began putting forward a program of ‘radical reform’ in the early 1990s. Using power resourcetheory this article reconstructs the internal logic of this strategy and argues that itspromise lay in its proffering of a solution to labor’s ‘developmental dilemma’. That dilemma,confronted by labor across the peripheries, arises from the fact that organizing at scale dependson structural changes in the economy that are inhibited by the absence of adequatecoordinating institutions. RR envisaged the use of state power and strategic compromiseto overcome market failures and enshrine a growth model that would be conducive to classformation. But the strategy collapsed as the ANC abandoned it and COSATU failed to rallyto its defense. Radical reform became neoliberal reform. As its structural power wilted awaythe labor federation took a conservative turn, adopting a strategy focused on safeguardingpartial victories. Using PRT again, this article offers a critique of this strategy, uncovering itsshort-termist orientation. But it also shows how several decades of neoliberalism have madeit far harder to achieve the positive class compromises upon which RR relies. The essence ofthe dilemma facing labor is that RR has become more urgent as the conditions for it havebecome far more complicated. The concluding section of this article offers tentative thoughtson a way forward, focused on a party political strategy.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Niall Reddy (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: