Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Complex abdominal wall hernias are still challenging. These patients require an extensive preoperative preparation, and, sometimes, the use of adjuvant techniques. Although some ratios (like Carbonell) are objectively estimate the surgical technique and the need of adjuvants preoperatively, Surgeon’s judgement is crucial for decision-making. Method This study aimed to evaluate a group of patients submitted to complex abdominal wall hernias correction after botulinum toxin administration (BTA) between 2012–2022, in order to evaluate a correlation between the choice of surgeon and Carbonell ratio. Results During this period, 38 patients were submitted to surgery (after BTA). BTA decision was used based on domain loss, wall rigidity and the size of the defect. Retrospectively, we applied the Carbonell ratio, and divided them in 3 groups. The first group (ratio <1) was composed by 23 patients, 19 did a bilateral component separation (BCS), 3 did a Rives-Stoppa with unilateral component separation (RS+UCS) and 1 patient did a Rives-Stoppa (RS). The second group (ratio 1–2), was composed by 13 patients, 6 did a BCS, 2 did a RS + UCS and 5 patients did a RS. The third group (ratio >2) had only 2 patients, 1 did BCS and the other RS. The recurrence rate was evaluated at two years both by clinical examination and image. We observed recurrence in 3 patients, 2 of them after BCS. Conclusion Based on this analysis, we can affirm that the use of objective measures might help the surgeons decide the best surgical approach and patient selection for adjuvant techniques.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Guimarães et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: