Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Historical analysis documents disaster response evolution in Singapore, suggesting improvements for future resilience.
INTRODUCTION The World Health Organization (WHO) defines mass casualty incidents as "disasters and major incidents which overwhelm local medical resources and compromise standard medical care."[1] This differs from a smaller-scale multiple casualty event, where resources are strained but still sufficient to provide standard medical care.[2] An effective medical response is important to minimise deaths and injuries in a mass casualty incident. The need for a special branch of medicine dedicated to disasters was first recognised in 1975.[3] In Singapore, high-rise buildings are vulnerable to strong seismic events.[4] Flooding also occurs.[5,6] Man-made disasters are more common. In the 1950s, there were frequent riots.[7,8] Other disasters include plane crash, terrorist bombing, tanker explosion, building collapse and train collision.[8] Singapore has also experienced novel infectious disease events, including the severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) outbreak and the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic.[9,10,11] Singapore continues to be at risk for mass casualty incidents and disasters; hence, it is important for the healthcare community to have a basic understanding of disaster response and management.[12] This article aimed to document the history of mass casualty events in Singapore, apprise the current state of healthcare response and suggest plans for future development. THE BEGINNINGS Singapore's worst acute disaster occurred in 1978 — a massive explosion on board the tanker, Spyros, at Jurong shipyard.[13,14,15,16] The disaster resulted in 145 casualties and 79 deaths. At that time, the country had no disaster plans. The two receiving hospitals, Singapore General Hospital and Alexandra Hospital, were quickly overwhelmed. Hence, the National Civil Defence Plan was formulated in 1982.[17] The Singapore Civil Defence Force (SCDF) became the incident manager (IM) for civil disasters, while the Ministry of Health (MOH) was responsible for on-site medical support. It was envisaged then that medical support would be provided by a single medical team comprising one doctor and two nurses from the hospital farthest from the disaster site. This plan was utilised in 1986 during the collapse of the Hotel New World building.[18] Unfortunately, the on-site medical response was suboptimal with minimal equipment, and the Singapore Armed Forces' (SAF) Medical Corps had to be brought in to heavily supplement the medical response.[19] By 1989, MOH and the nation's emergency medicine physicians had made significant revisions to the civilian disaster medical plan.[20] They established the Disaster Site Medical Command (DSMC) and formulated a comprehensive medical support plan for civil emergencies. The DSMC works closely with the on-site IM and includes field medical teams (FMT), each consisting of two doctors and four nurses from all public hospitals that are equipped with standardised medical supplies. Additional FMT from the primary health services can be activated when needed. Also tasked all public acute hospitals to form emergency preparedness committees to coordinate in-hospital response for mass casualty events. These plans have remained till today. THE PRESENT National emergency management system Singapore utilises a whole-of-government integrated risk management policy framework for disaster management.[21] The national emergency management system is helmed by the Homefront Crisis Management Committee (HCMC), which guides policymaking at the strategic level. At the operational level, HCMC oversees crisis management groups (CMG) from various ministries, including MOH. The CMG-MOH oversees all relevant healthcare-related operations during a disaster. Figure 1 illustrates this command-and-control system, which was also utilised during the SARS outbreak and the COVID-19 pandemic.[22,23]Figure 1: Overview of the National Management System in Singapore, CMG: crisis management group, HQ: headquartersDisaster site management The SCDF remains the IM for most acute disasters. Predisaster, the IM optimises emergency preparedness through planning and training. During a disaster, the IM works closely with DSMC to facilitate casualty flow and resource management.[20,24,25] Activation of Operation Civil Emergency triggers a cascade of events. Notably, FMT from all public acute hospitals are deployed to the disaster site. Additional waves of FMT from the public hospitals, polyclinics, SAF and Singapore Red Cross may also be deployed. The minimum requirements for FMT members include reasonable clinical seniority and completion of appropriate training programmes. All on-site medical elements report to DSMC. Full-scale disaster exercises are held regularly. An example is FEREX (Ferry Rescue Exercise), which simulates a ferry sinking.[26] The Maritime Port Authority is the IM that coordinates the rescue vessels from SCDF, SAF and Singapore Police Force to secure the area of operations and evacuate casualties. Once casualties arrive at the harbour, DSMC headquarters (HQ) and its FMT provide medical care in a first aid post (FAP) before evacuation to hospitals. Healthcare facility disaster management All public hospitals are involved in civil emergency situations.[25] Mandatory functional exercises are assessed by MOH regularly. These exercises stress test the processes in the casualty journey from arrival to discharge. All clinical and ancillary departments are involved. Private healthcare facilities may be activated to provide additional support, according to the Requisition of Resources Act enacted in 1985.[27] Hazardous materials considerations The 1984 Bhopal gas leak disaster and the 1995 Tokyo sarin gas attacks reinforced the need to plan for hazardous materials (HAZMAT) disasters.[28,29] Today, medical toxicologists serve as advisors to MOH, while SCDF provides on-site HAZMAT response. The HAZMAT units conduct rapid assessment, search and rescue, as well as evacuation and decontamination using specialised vehicles before sending casualties to FAP or hospitals. Every public hospital has decontamination facilities and HAZMAT response plans.[30] Disaster medicine education Disaster medicine is not formally incorporated into the syllabi of local medical schools. Recent studies of local medical students demonstrated low familiarity with disaster medical response, with the majority of the opinion that they can contribute effectively if they receive formal training.[31,32] Ad hoc courses in disaster management for doctors have been conducted since 1992. Basic training in disaster medicine forms a small part of the national emergency medicine postgraduate residency curriculum. There are currently no specialist disaster medicine fellowship programmes in Singapore or overseas for which the Specialist Accreditation Board has provided subspecialty certification. GOALS FOR DISASTER MEDICINE IN SINGAPORE While disasters may occur infrequently, the consequences, when they do happen, are often significant. As disasters usually occur at unexpected times having a operationally ready healthcare workforce that is mentally and logistically prepared will go a long way towards managing future disaster events. This would require a proactive approach to the training of healthcare workers in, at least, the essentials of disaster management. An evidence-based approach to education and training relevant to the local context would be appropriate. Out of the generally accepted seven levels of qualifications for training and education recommended for disaster medicine, Singapore currently offers only up to level three.[33] There is a need for a graduated programme of education for practitioners and disaster medicine experts to build up a strong cadre of healthcare professionals and organisations adequately versed in the principles and practice of disaster management in its various forms.[34] An academic institution that provides such a graduated programme would require a faculty who not only have the passion to teach, but also conduct necessary research on various aspects of disaster science and education. Movement in this direction would require recognition of the existence of disaster medicine as a subspeciality. Only then will practitioners begin to understand the need for and accept programmes run under this discipline, especially if it is housed in a tertiary academic institution. Academic recognition can lead to valuable contributions to the local understanding of disaster risk and its reduction, guiding policymaking.[35,36] Singapore continues to face increasing threats to its safety and security.[37] Complex, coordinated terrorist attacks involving multiple sites are concerning.[38,39] Hospitals are also increasingly becoming targets of terrorism, highlighting the importance of safeguarding these assets through updated risk assessments and development of robust business continuity plans.[40,41] Paediatric disaster preparedness is another area of concern, and there is a need for ongoing measures to enhance capabilities of adult hospitals to absorb paediatric casualties and conduct paediatric-centric exercises.[42] Operational readiness must be quantifiable with evidence of improvement. Efforts are currently being made to use validated matrices, structured debriefs and after-action reports to assess full-scale exercises. Technology and innovation can also enhance operations.[43] Data modelling and simulation and the integration of disaster site casualty information into hospital databases can help enhance disaster preparation and response. Wearable technology may also enhance the processes of casualty identification, tagging, monitoring and evacuation.[44] Collective vigilance and appropriate interventions from the community within the first few minutes of a disaster can limit life and property losses.[45] Such resilience can be achieved through public engagement and community skills training developed by disaster medicine experts. A national disaster FMT from Singapore was last deployed during the 2014 Nepal earthquake.[46] In 2023, MOH embarked on the WHO emergency medical team certification process.[47] Singapore also participates in regional meetings and drills under the ASEAN Regional Capacity on Disaster Health Management project,[48] and has conducted disaster preparedness courses in neighbouring countries, upon invitation.[49,50,51] These international collaborations must continue with vigour. In conclusion, Singapore has faced devastating disasters in the past and learnt painful lessons on its way to developing its current disaster medical response capabilities. As we commemorate the past and celebrate present achievements, we must also continue to pursue excellence. Anchoring disaster care firmly in the specialities of medicine should be considered as a way forward. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Quah et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: