Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: Uncomfortable Television by Hunter Hargraves Jorie Lagerwey (bio) Uncomfortable Television by Hunter Hargraves. Duke University Press. 2023. 264 pages. $99.95 hardcover; $26.95 paper; also available in e-book. Uncomfortable Television analyzes post-millennial US television through the lens of discomfort and the affects associated with taking pleasure in shows whose protagonists are unlikeable, criminal, gross, abject, narcissistic, or otherwise generally unpleasant. Hunter Hargraves's core argument is that post-millennial television "began to normalize discomfort during this time as a strategy of governmentality."1 Twentieth-century television, he argues, was designed to comfort, to instruct postwar American audiences on family structures and suburban living. Twenty-first century television dramatically shifted that affective address toward negative affects that Hargraves covers chapter by chapter: irritation, addiction, perversion, and White guilt.2 Training viewers to take pleasure in these "ugly feelings," to borrow Sianne Ngai's phrase, television enacts its governmentality, its role as a structure of cultural control, and accustoms audiences to enjoying feeling bad.3 This perversion of pleasure, Hargraves argues, is essential to surviving as a citizen in what is alternately titled late capitalism or neoliberal capitalism. This reimagining of the so-called affective theoretical turn in the humanities generally offers an interesting perspective on television studies as a field, an area of media studies Hargraves calls on to be more self-critical. [End Page 203] The two terms late capitalism and neoliberal capitalism form an essential backbone of the book's arguments, and it is sometimes assumed that there is a preexisting shared idea of what those words mean. That gloss, however, potentially reinforces the point itself: that "systems of economic precarity and cultural instability"—to which it would be safe, I think, to add ecological crisis, a pandemic, and broad antagonism toward difference in the forms of race, gender, sexuality, ability, and class—feel (to borrow the book's focus on affect) so widely shared as to not require detailed enumeration or intense interrogation. This shared structure of feeling goes hand in hand with Hargraves's acknowledgment of the inevitable messiness of periodization. To address that messiness in relation to his text selections, Hargraves usefully traces the several previous eras labeled television golden ages before settling into his analysis of early twenty-first-century "peak TV."4 The uncomfortable TV in the book's title, then, begins just at the turn of the millennium, growing from the much-celebrated antiheroes who emerged starting with Tony Soprano in 1999 (The Sopranos, HBO, 1999–2007) and proliferating in the first two decades of the twenty-first century with Breaking Bad (AMC, 2008–2013), Sons of Anarchy (FX, 2008–2014), Oz (HBO, 1997–2003; obviously before Tony Soprano, but without Soprano's cultural pervasiveness at the time), and The Wire (HBO, 2002–2008). Expanding beyond the "difficult men" discussed in work by Brett Martin and Amanda Lotz, Hargraves includes the irritating women on Girls (HBO, 2012–2017), addicted women (in the specific episode used as a case study) and men on the reality addiction drama Intervention (A&E, 2005–), and queer remix culture as seen on YouTube, particularly Jiz (2009–2016), a queer remix of Jem and the Holograms (syndicated, 1985–1988) obsessed with (satirical) gross and graphic encouragement of abortion.5 Uncomfortable Television is organized into five chapters, with each tackling a particular uncomfortable affect: irritation, addiction (both the pleasures of watching addicted people and the pleasure of addiction to television itself), perversion (specifically of uncritical nostalgia), and White guilt. A concluding chapter then grapples with the misrecognition of viewing discomfort for political action in what Hargraves describes as "woke TV."6 The initial chapters do much of the theoretical heavy lifting, situating the book in the trajectories of affect studies and the history of television studies as a field. The methodological push toward affect studies usefully recalls that emotions, pleasure, and viewers have been at the center of much feminist television studies since the field's inception, albeit not necessarily under the moniker or with the vocabulary of affect studies as its own field of research. Chapter 1 grounds its intervention within the now-prominent trend of affect studies within television studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2024 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: