Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: Interruptions in Early Modern English Drama by Michael M. Wagoner Sarah E. Johnson Interruptions in Early Modern English Drama. By Michael M. Wagoner. London: Bloomsbury, 2023. Pp. x + 284. Hardcover $115. Paperback $39.95. Ebook $35.95. Michael M. Wagoner's Interruptions in Early Modern English Drama makes a compelling case for treating interruptions as a distinct textual form, arguing that this approach reveals authorial style and "the theatrical dynamics between characters as well as between performance and audience" (3). Wagoner theorizes interruptions, provides a useful vocabulary for categorizing and analyzing them, and successfully applies both theory and terminology to analyses of selected scenes from plays by three major early modern playwrights: William Shakespeare, Ben Jonson, and John Fletcher. The terminology Wagoner offers in the introductory "Anatomy of Interruptions" will help anyone studying drama to perceive and discuss the complexities of interruption with more precision. Wagoner breaks all interruptions into three parts: premise, rupture, and continuation. The outcome of any given interruption "exist[s] on a spectrum from no change to complete change" and depends upon how these three parts work together (4). Does the continuation "meld the premise with the rupture" to create a "new expectation" (4)? Does the rupture "dominate, completely taking over the premise," or does the continuation "ignore the rupture and follow the premise's initial path" (4)? This breakdown opens up interruptions—which might at first seem fleeting and straightforward—to detailed analysis attentive to these discrete and dynamic points of consideration. It also makes apparent the formal complexity of interruptions. As Wagoner explains, for example, the dash, an emergent punctuation mark for signaling interruption at the beginning of the seventeenth century, is at once a break between a premise and a new premise (the rupture), and a bridge between them. The dash thus connects as much as it disrupts. (Exploring this potential for connection within interruption, Wagoner later persuasively argues that community-building interruptions are typical of Fletcher's style.) He further classifies interruptions into two main categories, each with their own subdivisions: microinterruptions (divided into dialogic, self, and action interruptions) and macrointerruptions (divided into interruptions of dramaturgy and of theatrical conventions). This [End Page 121] classification establishes a useful basis for understanding the most common rhetorical effects of a given type of interruption and for recognizing anomalies. The distinction between micro- and macrointerruptions, moreover, alerts readers to the connections between interruptions that occur "as a specific moment within the work," such as Hamlet's ghost interrupting Bernardo, and interruptions that operate on a larger scale (9). An example of the latter is the statue scene in The Winter's Tale. Wagoner argues that this scene departs from "almost every other plot" in Shakespeare's canon by "avoiding obvious dramatic irony," thus disrupting audience expectations related to dramaturgy (136). Approaching interruptions as a form enables more scrutinizing analysis, but what is the value in uncovering their complexity? Wagoner argues for the significance of each category of interruption, but on the whole, interruptions often have to do with power. Dialogic interruptions, in particular, "are built upon relationships, which imply hierarchical structures of power. These structures further dictate the use and effect of these interruptions as issues of rank, status, gender, [and] race" (10). The power dynamics within microinterruptions, in turn, play a part in shaping identity (27). A more anatomizing study of interruptions, then, could reveal power struggles and identity formations with increased accuracy. Even self-interruptions can serve as a means of manipulating others, and macrointerruptions can manipulate audience members by playing with their expectations, as Wagoner demonstrates. Wagoner does not set the relational hierarchies of status, gender, and race as a focus of his study, but he does offer perceptive analyses of status and gender through attending to interruption. His examination of editorial interventions in the placement of the female characters' singing in Fletcher's The Tamer Tamed, for instance, illuminates how interruption can impact the representation of gender. While early editions of the play indicate the song of Maria and company erupting during and over the conversation of men, Wagoner shows how later editions softened this rupture by moving it after the men's conversation and therefore attenuated the women...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2024 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: