Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This analysis demonstrates how CAPM should be viewed as associational, indicating that beta may not reliably predict asset returns.
The CAPM regression is typically interpreted as if the market return contemporaneously causes individual returns, motivating beta-neutral portfolios and factor attribution. For realized equity returns, however, this interpretation is inconsistent: a same-period arrow Rm,t → Ri,t conflicts with the fact that Rₘ is itself a value-weighted aggregate of its constituents, unless Rₘ is lagged or leave-one-out -- the ``aggregator contradiction.'' We formalize CAPM as a structural causal model and analyze the admissible three-node graphs linking an external driver Z, the market Rₘ, and an asset Rᵢ. The empirically plausible baseline is a fork, Z → ₘ, Rᵢ\, not Rₘ → Rᵢ. In this setting, OLS beta reflects not a causal transmission, but an attenuated proxy for how well Rₘ captures the underlying driver Z. Consequently, ``beta-neutral'' portfolios can remain exposed to macro or sectoral shocks, and hedging on Rₘ can import index-specific noise. Using stylized models and large-cap U.S.\ equity data, we show that contemporaneous betas act like proxies rather than mechanisms; any genuine market-to-stock channel, if at all, appears only at a lag and with modest economic significance. The practical message is clear: CAPM should be read as associational. Risk management and attribution should shift from fixed factor menus to explicitly declared causal paths, with ``alpha'' reserved for what remains invariant once those causal paths are explicitly blocked.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Noal Cohen (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: