Analysis finds disparities in predicted versus measured resting metabolic rate in obese youth, indicating the need for tailored equations.
Background: Achieving and maintaining a healthy weight is one of the AHA’s Life’s Essential 8. Estimating resting metabolic rate (RMR) facilitates weight loss counseling, which is a key aspect to therapeutic lifestyle change in youth with hypertension. RMR equations were established in variable populations; it is unknown how these equations perform in youth with significant obesity. Objective: Determine the agreement between measured and predicted RMR among youth with obesity and elevated blood pressure (BP). Methods: Pediatric patients with obesity and elevated BP who were referred for hypertension evaluation underwent indirect calorimetry using a Vmax Encore metabolic cart after fasting, abstaining from nicotine use x4 hrs, and avoiding vigorous physical activity x12 hrs. Paired t-tests compared measured to estimated RMR obtained using predictive equations (kcal/day; Table 1). Comparisons were made for the population overall and stratified by sex and race. Bland-Altman plots illustrated the overall mean difference and the limits of agreement (LOA). Results: Thirty-one youth, 6-20 yrs of age [mean 14 yrs, standard deviation (SD) 3.3] participated: 35% female (n=11), 68% (n=21) Black, mean weight 114.9 kg (SD 35.9), and mean BMI 41.31 kg/m2 (SD 9.9). Measured and estimated RMR are displayed in Table 2. There was no bias detected and there were minimal/no outliers (Figure). The Harris-Benedict, a commonly used equation in clinical practice which was developed in Caucasian individuals of normal weight, had an overall mean difference of +176 kcal/day when compared to measured RMR and had a slightly greater overestimation among male and Black youth (~200 kcal/day). The Mifflin St. Jeor, developed in a population whose racial composition was not specified but had a large proportion of individuals with obesity (47%), best estimated RMR for all participants with an overall mean difference of -24 kcal/day and nearly identical estimated-to-measured RMR in each subgroup of sex and race. Conclusion: In this study of majority Black youth 6-20 yrs of age with obesity, we found significant differences between the predicted and measured RMR. The Mifflin-St. Jeor predictive equation provided the best estimate of RMR, highlighting the importance of diversified patient populations when developing predictive equations for use in the general pediatric population.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Moore et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: