Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Quantitative evaluation shows differences in handover quality between civilian and military units, suggesting areas for improvement.
Introduction The terrorist wave in Europe of the 2010s, the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in Ukraine highlight the relevance of disaster medicine and the importance of civil-military coordination to enhance health interventions. However, differences in communication patterns between military and civilian healthcare have been reported, becoming apparent in patient handovers and potentially impacting their quality. This impact has not been quantitatively verified, making it difficult to assess the effectiveness of potential interventions. Objective This study quantitatively investigates whether handover quality differs between civilian and military prehospital units during a disaster medicine field exercise. Methods Four external observers—three junior physicians and one senior medical student—used the Emergency Department Human Factors in Handover tool (ED-HFH) to evaluate civilian and military handovers during LIV 2025, a disaster medicine field exercise in Sweden. Prior to the exercise, the observers tested the tool on real-life handovers. The ED-HFH consists of 14 items assessing communication, teamwork, and situational awareness, each scored on a Likert scale, generating a total sum score between 14 and 70 and an overall quality rating of 1 to 10. All structured handovers from participating civilian and military units during the exercise were eligible for inclusion. Due to non-normal distributions, Mann-Whitney U tests were used to compare median sum scores and overall ratings between groups. Results A total of 46 handovers, equally divided between civilian and military, were observed. Ten handovers were assessed by two observers to determine inter-rater reliability, resulting in a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.886 for sum scores and 0.906 for overall ratings. There were four missing data points across four handovers. They were excluded for the affected analyses. The civilian group had a median sum score of 51 out of 70 (figure 1), while the military group had 45; however, this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.222). In contrast, overall ratings were significantly higher for the civilian group (median 6 vs. 4 out of 10; p = 0.026). Abstract P01 Figure 1 Box plots of sum score distribution for the civilian and military group respectively. Outliers are marked with dots outside the whiskers Item-level analysis revealed significant group differences on four questionnaire items, three related to human factors (lower in the military group) and one to case complexity (higher in the military group). Spearman’s rho analyses showed significant positive correlations between all but one human factor item and overall rating. The items with the strongest correlations were identified for further analysis. Conclusion A difference in handover quality between civilian and military units participating in Liv 2025 is suggested by the results from the overall ratings; however, this was not supported by the ED-HFH sum scores, possibly due to limited sample size affecting the tool’s performance. One item, related to the complete transfer of relevant information, was rated significantly lower in the military group and showed strong correlation with overall ratings, which may present a target for future research or intervention. Conflicts of Interest No relevant conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sandgren et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: