Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Analysis reports on soil health and quality in California agroecosystems, indicating potential for improved ecosystem services.
Soil health is an expanding discipline with implications for research, policy, and agribusiness. A key soil health tenet is the integrated assessment of the three dimensions of physical, chemical, and biological properties. Yet, few studies have examined whether research meets this goal or differs from decades of soil quality work. This study evaluated how soil health and soil quality research assessed these dimensions under different management practices in California's agroecosystems. We mapped the ecosystem services linked to indicators within each dimension to understand the implications for multifunctional agroecosystems. We identified 43 articles using the term “soil quality” from 1976 until 2024 and 26 articles using “soil health,” the latter appearing for the first time in 2015, highlighting a recent growing interest. Cover crops dominated soil health studies (30%), whereas organic amendments and wastewater management were the most frequent practices for soil quality (31% and 24%, respectively). Almost 85% of soil health papers measured a biological component compared to 60% for soil quality, supporting the driver of the soil health discipline. Soil physical and chemical properties were less studied, meaning research on soil quality has been similar, if not more comprehensive than soil health (51% vs. 46%, respectively). Most indicators were associated with supporting soil fertility and nutrient cycling, highlighting the need for more attention on food production, soil carbon sequestration, and water regulation. Regardless of terminology, this review suggests that research has not comprehensively assessed soils. Integrated assessments are crucial for benefiting farmers and providing multiple ecosystem services for society.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Roel‐Rezk et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: