Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Analysis reveals efficiency gains from SMD MOSFETs in power electronics applications, suggesting significant cost reductions.
This work presents an overview and comparative analysis of surface‐mounted devices (SMDs) and pin‐through‐hole (PTH) low‐voltage MOSFETs (LV, tens of volts) for power electronics in industrial equipment. A commercial 1 kW full‐bridge inverter, powered by a 24 V battery is evaluated. Efficiency and cost are analysed using the Pareto front in a database of 200 MOSFETs, including packages of PTH (TO220) and SMD (DPAK, , TOLL, SuperSO8). The results indicate that SMD technologies, especially , SuperSO8, and TOLL, significantly improve efficiency over TO220 MOSFETs. This efficiency increase allows to halve the number of MOSFETs used in the commercial product by eliminating parallelism. A heat transfer evaluation is conducted to verify the feasibility of using a single MOSFET per position for both PTH and SMD designs. For TO220 MOSFETs, the original PCB equipment is considered. For SMD designs, the influence of thermal vias configuration is analysed in four different PCB layouts, under natural convection and forced airflow (parallel and perpendicular to the PCB). The thermal resistances of all designs are experimentally evaluated. The results for TO220 show that only one part number was feasible, which allowed a cost reduction of 25.8%. The results for the SMD designs show that the natural convection had the highest thermal resistances, which made all designs infeasible. Under forced airflow, changing airflow from parallel to perpendicular to the PCB reduces thermal resistance and achieves cost reductions. The greatest cost reductions were found with perpendicular forced airflow, achieving 73.7% for and 81.6% for SuperSO8.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Prado et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: