Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Exploratory study highlights environmental risks in vessel disposal, suggesting the need for international standards and ship recycling.
Objective: This study investigates sustainability in the disposal stage of the life cycle (LC) of Brazilian Navy (BN) military vessels, based on the perceptions of BN professionals. Theoretical Framework: The disposal of naval assets is a complex area of international and national law. It involves the safe decommissioning of ships at the end of their useful life. Proper ship recycling seeks to minimize environmental impacts, especially in relation to the disposal of toxic materials, and encourages the recycling of components. Despite its sovereign immunity, previous studies and cases show that the Brazilian Navy faces difficulties in implementing sustainable measures due to regulatory and financial barriers. The concepts of Life Cycle Management (LCM) and circular economy (CE), aligned with international legislation such as the Hong Kong Convention (IMO, 2009), the European Union Ship Recycling Regulation (SRR), and the Basel Convention (UNITED NATIONS, 1989) are essential for the formulation of sustainable strategies, as are the strategic frameworks of National Defense, such as the National Defense Policy (PDN), National Defense Strategy (END), Brazilian Naval Policy (PNB), and Navy Strategic Plan (PEM), also referenced here. Method: An exploratory qualitative approach was adopted, including a literature review using scientific sources and official documents, aligned with an online questionnaire answered by 35 experts from the Brazilian Navy's Naval Engineering Directorate (DEN), all of which were valid. Results and Discussion: The results reveal that most experts demonstrate limited knowledge of international standards, with up to 38.5% stating that they are unaware of the Hong Kong Convention and 30.8% unaware of European initiatives. On the other hand, there is strong consensus on the importance of the issue: more than 90% recognize the environmental and health risks of dismantling, 92.3% agree that sustainable practices generate savings, and 69.2% express full support for the adoption of international standards. In addition, the entire sample (100%) considers the creation of internal guidelines to be urgent and believes that the debate on sustainable disposal should be expanded throughout the Force. Implications of the Research: The study highlights the urgent need for regulatory frameworks that can guide, train, and empower MB personnel in the disposal of military vessels, incorporating international legislation combined with ecological, economic, and logistical dimensions, as already employed by the navies of the United States, the European Union, and China. Originality/Value: This is one of the first studies to explore the disposal of military vessels from the perspective of Brazilian Navy experts, providing a comparative analysis with practices carried out in other navies for the same purposes. The results offer valuable insights for policymakers in the country's military naval sector.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Antunes et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: