Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This research discusses biofeedback's clinical effects and unresolved issues in treatment guidelines.
Development of the current empirically oriented view of autonomic nervous system learning within a feedback framework is dicussed with attention paid to issues such as mediation and the choice of yoked control designs in experimental settings.Difficulties in establishing and assessing clinical changes, using a closed loop model, are discussed in terms of recent subvocalspeaking and heart rate research.A discussion of clinically oriented treatment guidelines focuses on three areas: response measurement, feedback information, and shaping.While there have been clear and positive clinical effects, the authors concluded that the factors which combine to produce an enhanced curative effect are not sufficiently delineated at this time.Biofeedback procedures and techniques have been gammg exposure m professional journals in recent years.This paper hopes to illuminate and illustrate several frequently occuring problematic themes in the current literature.EMPIRICAL DEVELOPMENT AND HISTORY Classical (Pavlovian) and Operant (Skinnerian) learning paradigms have represented the core of learning theory construction for many years.Popularly held views of nervous system functioning were also colored by these formulations.Recently, work done by several investigators (Fowler & Kimmel, 1962;DiCara, 1970;Miller, 1969;Miller & DiCara, 1967;Miller & DiCara, 1968), have caused this traditionally held belief to be questioned.As much as anyone else, assertions by Neal Miller (DiCara, 1970) that the classical conditioning of visceral responses and the instrumental learning of skeletal responses represent the same phoenomenon under slightly different conditions, have stimulated a reformulation of the traditional learning dichotomy.Miller arrived at this position after demonstrating that both kinds oflearning seemed to display marked similarities with regard to three basic characteristics: discrimination, retention, and response specificity.While other laboratories have confirmed Miller's original findings, Hahn and Slaughter (1970) note that although the procedures for shaping HR responses in the curarized rat may appear deceptively simple, obtaining reliable HR changes under curare is much more difficult.Miller (1972a) concurs in his review and notes the trend finding smaller learned differences in the last several years.Yet, all of the phenomena of instrumental training involving skeletal responses have turned out to be characteristic of visceral conditioning as well.To Miller (1969),
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
FARR et al. (1975) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: