Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Historical analysis reveals Buffalo Bill's evolving views on Mormons and polygamy post-Manifesto.
Brent Rogers's excellent book recounts the life story of William Frederick Cody (1846–1917), best known as Buffalo Bill. As the title suggests, he focuses on Cody's connection with the Mormons. Prior to 1890 the shared stories of Cody and the Latter-day Saints were indirect and in some cases of questionable veracity. In fact, as Rogers notes, Cody's connection with the Mormons prior to that time were “largely inferred from his stage performances, autobiography, and other writings” that were written by others (7).Cody claimed that during the summer of 1857, he worked for the Russell, Majors, and Waddell company, which was fitting out wagons for the US Army so they could fulfill their orders to march to Utah and replace Brigham Young as governor. More than twenty years later Cody dictated an account that was surely exaggerated, and parts of which were fictitious, including the supply train's encounter with Mormon Danites that, in his telling, were commanded by “Joe Smith” (24–30).Following the Utah War, Cody served in the Union Army during the Civil War and was awarded the Medal of Honor during skirmishes with Indians. Beginning in 1872, he became an actor, where he played parts in The Scouts of the Prairie that included Mormons and Danites (45–48). Rogers notes that Mormonism in general and polygamy in particular were popular subjects during this period, and he surveys some of the exposés and fictional accounts that were published and plays that were performed (49–57).Rogers recounts that in 1877, Cody performed in the play May Cody, produced by his own company, which placed him at Mountain Meadows when the infamous massacre took place (57–66). In 1879 Cody and his company arrived in Salt Lake City, where they performed for two nights at the Salt Lake Theatre. Not surprisingly, the company did not perform May Cody but instead a new play, Knight of the Plains, which focused on his “shooting prowess” (66–68). During the same year, Cody's autobiography was published, which included vignettes concerning his efforts to combat the threat of Mormonism (68–71).In 1880 Cody performed in another stage play, entitled Prairie Wolf, that also included villainous Mormons in the plot. This play and other publications during the same decade reinforced stereotypes concerning Mormon polygamy and violence, which undoubtedly influenced congressional legislation that specifically attempted to resolve the “Mormon Question” (74–82).In 1883 Cody unveiled his new venture, the “Wild West” show, which performed in outdoor arenas during the summer and fall while he continued to act in plays during the winter (83–86). His Wild West show was eventually seen by writers such as Mark Twain, who was impressed by what he saw and who had included Mormons in his writing. (Buffalo Bill's Wild West show also influenced European writers Karl May and Emilio Salgari, though Rogers does not mention them.)In 1886, Cody performed in Utah again (in both Ogden and Salt Lake), but this time he did not hesitate to act in the anti-Mormon play Prairie Wolf (86–89). Throughout Rogers's book he recounts the federal government's various attempts to legislatively and judicially force the Mormons to abandon polygamy and how Cody's performances and other books contributed to the negative image of Mormonism (92–95).Following Wilford Woodruff's Manifesto instructing church members that plural marriages would no longer be sanctioned, Cody again visited Utah with a “new entourage” of military men including several Latter-day Saints (95–96). Cody's coterie traveled to southern Utah and northern Arizona. Following their return to Salt Lake City, Cody met with the LDS First Presidency and was impressed with the courtesy shown to him (98–108).Rogers notes that this encounter caused Cody to reassess his attitude toward the Mormons, and thereafter he made more measured comments about them (107–9). The following year he met members of the First Presidency again during the Chicago World's Fair, and they attended his Wild West show. Thereafter, Cody's statements concerning the accomplishments of the Latter-day Saints were very positive, as seen in his book The Great Salt Lake Trail (117–21, esp. 137–38).For the remainder of the book, Rogers discusses the economic connection between Cody and the Mormon leadership. Cody joined with apostle Abraham Woodruff to develop the Big Horn Basin and create the town of Cody in Wyoming. This enterprise, during which the Mormons built a road and dug a canal and Cody provided land and water rights, sometimes created tension between Cody, the church, and the non-Mormon residents in the area.Although Cody complained about the Mormons’ negotiating tactics, he praised the church as it became intertwined with his commercial interests and facilitated the creation of a settlement named for him (143–90). Yet a dime novel entitled Buffalo Bill's Mormon Quarrel, or At War with the Danites was used as an anti-Mormon prop during the Reed Smoot hearings (219–22).Cody apparently maintained a good rapport with the church's leadership. When he visited Salt Lake City in 1914 as part of the Sells-Floto Circus, he met again with the First Presidency and attended a special organ recital in the Tabernacle (226–27). The following year, during his last visit to Utah two years before he died, he again applauded the industriousness of the Latter-day Saints (229).In Rogers's conclusion he analyzes Cody's relationship with the Mormons and acknowledges that his modified views concerning the Saints could have been driven by self-interest. But he seems equally convinced that once Cody became acquainted with Mormons, his attitudes toward them were genuine (231–34). Rogers might have also analyzed whether the church also embraced Cody out of self-interest when it was attempting to mainstream following the abandonment of plural marriage.Rogers ends his narrative with the church's announcement in 2021 that a temple would be built in Cody, Wyoming. After that announcement and the publication of Buffalo Bill and the Mormons, there was a messy approval process, with some public outcry, which demonstrates that the shared story of Cody and the Mormons, with its ebbs and flows, continues to this day. The book is well written in a lucid style, fully annotated, with both primary and secondary sources, and a very useful index. I recommend it for both academics and those interested in Western history.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Michael W. Homer (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: