Diagnosing TOD in Gulf Heritage Cores Using the Integrated Modification Methodology (IMM): A Comparative Study of Souq Waqif (Doha) and Qasr Al Hokm (Riyadh)

This paper investigates the application of Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) principles to the retrofitting of historic Gulf urban cores through a comparative analysis of Souq Waqif (Doha) and Qasr Al Hokm (Riyadh). The research employs field observation, thematic mapping, and qualitative diagnosis using the Integrated Modification Methodology (IMM) to assess compactness, intricacy, and connectivity within walkable station catchments. The findings indicate that Souq Waqif has a highly compact and intricate historic core with robust pedestrian activity, yet exhibits discontinuities at its periphery, such as car-dominated streets, fragmented green spaces, and weak connections between the metro station, parks, and adjacent blocks. In Qasr Al Hokm, the analysis affirms the value of its fine-grained historic fabric and civic landmarks, but also identifies deficiencies in shading, last-mile connectivity, and land-use balance surrounding the new metro station. Drawing on lessons from Souq Waqif, the paper proposes a TOD-oriented urban design framework for Qasr Al Hokm, emphasizing shaded pedestrian corridors, active ground floors, intermodal hubs, and heritage-compatible mixed-use intensification. This comparative approach demonstrates how TOD can foster more livable, accessible, and climate-responsive historic cores in Gulf cities, while maintaining respect for local identity and governance structures.