Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The subspecialization of pediatric cardiac intensive care requires a reevaluation of medical education to ensure all relevant trainees maintain proficiency in caring for critically ill children with cardiac disease.
Subspecialization seems to be an inevitable process in most medical specialties, and this phenomenon is certainly occurring in critical care medicine. In most large tertiary or quaternary medical centers, critically ill adult patients are cared for in highly specialized ICUs. At a minimum, most large centers cluster appropriate patients into medical, neurologic, or surgical ICUs. In some institutions, however, the subspecialization of critical care medicine has been taken even further, and there are specialized units for the care of trauma victims, burn patients, or patients recovering from major cardiothoracic procedures or solid organ transplantation operations.The impetus for this change are the advantages that such subspecialization brings. Focused care encourages a dedicated team to develop skills and expand their knowledge in a very specific clinical domain. Repetition promotes expertise for all staff involved. Opportunities for focused education develop as physicians and other staff choose to dedicate themselves to a subspecialty.Subspecialization is now occurring in pediatric critical care medicine as well. Over the past decade, pediatric cardiac intensive care has evolved into a specialized branch of the ICU. As of the last report in 2004, there were 15 reported cardiac ICUs (CICUs) in the United States.1 It has fostered the creation of a distinct staff, specialized training, and a professional society. Cardiovascular surgeons and cardiologists have certainly stimulated proliferation of separate units for the care of their patients. Working with a small, familiar staff promotes uniform management. Communication and team building are easier when the group is consistent and established, and team leaders can capitalize on the resulting esprit de corps to foster continuing development and appropriate change.Numerous challenges have already been identified, such as the need to demonstrate strong physician and nurse leadership, maintain morale, and perfect a multidisciplinary approach.2,3 Another challenge is attracting and maintaining a workforce that is well qualified to care for such complex patients. Chang and Stromberg have addressed this need primarily through prescribing additional training.3 They have not addressed the impact on other trainees or given consideration to restructuring current programs to optimize the education of fellows who graduate from pediatric critical care, neonatology, and cardiology. These numbers are not small; currently, there are 49 pediatric cardiology fellowship programs, 61 pediatric critical care programs, and 97 neonatology programs registered with the Fellowship and Residency Electronic Interactive Database.4 Additional training may, in fact, be ideal but unrealistic.5 With heavy medical school debt and the temptation of lucrative staff positions, it is easy to see why recruitment for this field has been difficult. It is also important to consider that medical care for these patients does not occur in ICUs exclusively but also in private offices, emergency departments, urgent care clinics, and general pediatric wards. Are these medical personnel trained to care for them?The impact on training pediatric residents has been significant. Creating a subspecialty begets exclusion. Historically, pediatric residents have learned the basics of caring for critically ill children with cardiac pathology in the PICU, but they usually do not rotate through a CICU unless as an elective. As a result, they may feel less comfortable with cardiovascular disorders and surgical repair. Lack of familiarity breeds fear, and fear breeds dislike. This most likely decreases, rather than expands, the pool of trainees needed to populate this growing field. Those who chose other careers will be less able to provide knowledgeable support to families and more likely to refer patients to cardiologists or emergency departments for even the most routine care.Patients with cardiac problems were previously part of the daily census of PICUs and NICUs. Fellows who trained in these specialties were provided consistent exposure to patients with cardiac disorders. The paradigm for fellow education in cardiac intensive care has shifted in some institutions. Intense learning given in “bolus” doses has become an alternative to daily, “continuous” education. The impact of this change on knowledge at the conclusion of training is uncertain.Neonatology programs have particular difficulty ensuring sufficient experience with these patients for their trainees. In many centers with CICUs, once a cardiac diagnosis is made, commonly even prenatally, care of the patient is transferred from the NICU to the CICU. Because the creation of CICUs has not occurred in all hospitals, many fellows from both critical care and neonatology will practice at institutions where they will be neonatal “cardiac intensivists.” How do we ensure that they are qualified to serve in this role?When cardiology fellows are asked to function as the primary ICU fellow for patients with cardiac problems, they are more familiar than other trainees with the cardiovascular physiology, pathology, and medical and surgical therapies. On the other hand, they lack experience with airway management, multiorgan dysfunction, or other conditions that require general intensive care training.Survival after surgical repair or palliation of congenital heart disease continues to improve.6 However, many patients are discharged from the hospital with incomplete repair or residual morbidity. General pediatricians and emergency medicine physicians need to recognize common problems of these patients and feel comfortable with their anatomy and physiology. Unfortunately, as care of these patients is increasingly segregated, their exposure to these children will decrease.What is the impact of CICUs on meeting current training requirements? Pediatric critical care programs must make “available to the residents…at least 100 cases per year of patients who have undergone cardiovascular surgery.” Neonatology requires that “each resident should participate in the care of an adequate number of neonatal patients who require major surgery, including cardiac surgery, to become skilled in the diagnosis and management of these neonates.”6 Now that these patients are not included in the PICU and NICU populations in many institutions, new mechanisms for ensuring adequate education need to be defined.The current guidelines for pediatric emergency medicine training do not quantify the specific required training in pediatric cardiac intensive care. They assume that the fellowship will be tailored for the specific needs of each fellow and provide “opportunities for further training.”7 The guidelines do not demand a minimum proficiency. What about adult emergency medicine residents? Current program requirements do not specifically address pediatric cardiac disease.The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education Residency Review Committee for pediatric cardiology has stated that “there must be an intensive care unit in each center in which patients with heart disease are cared for under the supervision of the training program staff and are available to the residents.”7 It has not specified the type of ICU or the training of the intensive care faculty. The ICU experience provides the opportunity for fellows to meet specific requirements for “resuscitation techniques” including pericardiocentesis, thoracentesis, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, mechanical ventilation, cardioversion, and temporary pacing. With the creation of CICUs, more cardiology fellows are assuming more responsibility for tasks that were previously accomplished by critical care fellows. What will be the impact on proficiency?Any decision to create a separate unit is fraught with difficulty. A divide is created that may be deepened by politics, emotion, and, often, physical space. Decisions about appropriate staffing and appropriate distribution of patients risk tension and potential competition, which can breed a deeper separation than ideal for the care of patients and the education of fellows. Conferences, including morbidity and mortality reviews and patient care discussions, often fall under the direction of either critical care or cardiology rather than remaining unified with multispecialty participation.This period of transition provides an opportunity to shape this field and benefit all critically ill patients. Cross-fertilization rather than competition is essential. There are research opportunities in the cardiac population that may impact other critically ill patients and vice versa. Greater knowledge of the impact of deep hypothermic cardiac arrest in the operating room may provide insight into treatment of cardiac arrest in other pediatric patients. Mechanisms and management of multiorgan failure resulting from cardiogenic shock may be informed by multiorgan failure resulting from septic shock, and vice versa. As we begin to repair more complex lesions in patients with greater comorbidity, and as all patients live longer, their postoperative management becomes more complex. Application of ventilator strategies for acute respiratory distress syndrome and renal replacement therapies for renal insufficiency are likely to be required more frequently and merit rich interaction between cardiac and general intensivists.We recognize that the question of ideal training and even the definition of a cardiac intensivist are matters of an ongoing heated debate,8,9 but they are not the focus of this commentary. The strength of feeling only reinforces the need for open discussion and collaboration among cardiologists, intensivists, pediatricians, neonatologists, and emergency medicine practitioners about training. The trend toward cardiac specialization exists and has consequences on resident and fellow education. It not only impacts future cardiologists and intensivists but also general pediatricians, neonatologists, and emergency department physicians.Potential approaches to addressing the educational issues include the following: We recommend that a task force be formed that includes representatives from general pediatrics, critical care medicine, cardiac intensive care, cardiology, neonatology, and emergency medicine to evaluate the current training in these specialties to ensure an appropriate incorporation of cardiac and general intensive care medicine into each curriculum. Specific questions for the group include: (1) What are the goals related to cardiac care for each group? (2) What experience is required for residents and fellows to become proficient in cardiac intensive care? (3) How can we optimize cooperation between cardiology and intensive care in patient care, education, and research? and (4) What will enhance necessary recruitment into the workforce for such specialized care?We thank Ann E. Thompson, MD, and Mitchell P. Fink, MD, for guidance and editorial contributions to this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Su et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: