Key result
The authors propose a revised 7- to 8-year combined training pathway to preserve the quadruple-boarded pediatric critical care anesthesiologist and ensure the specialty's future.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors propose a shortened, combined training pathway to preserve the role of the quadruple-boarded pediatric critical care anesthesiologist.
Over the past 50 years, the specialty of anesthesiology has spawned 4 entirely new branches of medicine: critical care medicine; pain medicine; quality and safety medicine; and simulation-based medical education. During this same time period, the specialty evolved into recognized subspecialties, and the American Board of Anesthesiology began offering subspecialty certification in 5 fields: pediatrics; critical care; pain; sleep; and hospice and palliative medicine. Pediatric critical care medicine, initially a subspecialty of pediatric anesthesia, was born, like its adult counterparts, from the practice of anesthesiology in the 1970s.1,2 Initially modeled as an extension of the postoperative recovery room, early pediatric intensive care units, like adult surgical intensive care units, were staffed by anesthesiologists for surgical patients, and were designed to support patients with failing ventilation and to provide continuous vital sign monitoring.2,3 The role of anesthesiologists was logical and practical: they ran the postanesthesia care units and were the recognized experts in resuscitation, intubation, airway management, and mechanical ventilation. Over time, these first pediatric intensive care units increasingly cared for medical as well as surgical patients. Consequently, the background and number of intensivists staffing these units dramatically shifted. Pediatric intensive care unit attending physicians and leadership roles in pediatric critical care medicine became dominated by board-certified pediatricians and pediatric subspecialists. Indeed, today, as described in the current issue,4 American pediatric critical care anesthesiologists are an endangered, vanishing species, overshadowed in pediatric intensive care units by pediatric subspecialists (cardiologists and intensivists). How did we get here? Is this situation salvageable, or are we like the woolly mammoth, on the road to, or already at the point of, extinction? And more significantly for the specialty, why is this concern important? In the early 1980s, an attempt was made to form a conjoint Board of Critical Care Medicine representing anesthesiology, internal medicine, surgery, and pediatrics.1,3,5 Unfortunately, the component boards could not agree on training qualifications, and the initiative failed. By 1986, each of the specialty boards created their own training criteria and separate certification examinations, with the only common denominator being a minimum of 5 years of postgraduate training. Thus, the American Board of Anesthesiology, which has a 4-year residency requirement, mandated only 1 year of additional training in critical care medicine. On the other hand, the American Board of Pediatrics, which has a 3-year residency training requirement, exceeded the agreed-upon 5 years of postgraduate training. The American Board of Pediatrics mandated not only 2 years of clinical critical care medicine training, but also an additional mandatory 1 year of research in a pediatric critical care medicine–related area. This total of 6 years of graduate medical education matches the requirements for other fellowship training programs in subspecialties such as pediatric pulmonology, cardiology, neonatology, etc.3 Unfortunately, the American Board of Pediatrics gives no credit for any time spent in an anesthesiology residency or fellowship. Thus, for individuals interested in dual pediatric and anesthesiology residency and fellowship training, this 6-year American Board of Pediatrics training requirement, in addition to 3–4 years of anesthesiology training and a 1-year pediatric anesthesia fellowship, is simply, in the current time of enormous medical school debt, kryptonite. No one, except perhaps the independently wealthy, can realistically be expected to complete 10 or more years of graduate medical education, with college and medical school debts averaging well over $200,000 (and climbing). Further, the more favorable economic and working conditions in operating room anesthesia drive “double-boarded” (really, “quadruple-boarded”: anesthesiology, pediatrics, pediatric anesthesia, and pediatric critical care medicine) physicians away from the pediatric intensive care unit toward the operating room. Considering these economic realities, as a profession, we must rethink how we train the next generation of physicians. Anesthesiologists have a long and proud history of investigative endeavors in medicine, biology, physiology, pharmacology, and quality and safety science. And yet, in our current paradigm of postgraduate medical education, much of this is currently very much at risk. Indeed, we are at a crossroads, with fewer and fewer fellowship-trained physicians interested in research and even fewer trained for competitive extramural grant funding. Further, by any measure, our current 1-year American Board of Anesthesiology fellowship training programs in pediatric anesthesiology have failed at producing the next generation of clinician scientists and leaders. The lone exception has been the few programs and individual quadruple-boarded, pediatric critical care anesthesiologists who have a mandatory research year as part of their training. In recent editorials on the advanced pediatric anesthesiology fellowship, McGowan and Davis6 and Andropoulos et al7 outlined the obstacles confronting the academic advancement of the specialty. Most notably, they describe the lack of research training of the specialty, the relative paucity of pediatric anesthesia mentorship, and the inability of programs to commit both time and money to research. Like the Irish monks of the Dark Ages who saved civilization by keeping the tradition of scholarship alive, we believe that the spark of scholarship and leadership in our profession is best being kept alive by the quadruple-boarded pediatric anesthesia intensivists. Indeed, we believe that our very survival as a profession depends on keeping this critical care training track alive and emulating and transferring many of the skill sets to our standard pediatric anesthesia fellowship training pathways. As discussed by Longacre et al,4 an essential element in preventing the extinction of the quadruple-boarded pediatric critical care anesthesiologist is to shorten the training period for these individuals to a maximum of 7 or 8 years. The American Board of Anesthesiology/American Board of Pediatrics–approved combined 5-year residency track approved in 2013 is a good first start. This pathway allows completion of an anesthesia and pediatrics residency in 5 rather than 6 years. We believe that a simple solution to this training duration conundrum would be to creatively change year 5 of the basic residencies and combine the pediatric anesthesia and pediatric critical care fellowships in years 6 and 7. In our revised pathway, year 5 of residency for these individuals would be devoted solely to pediatric anesthesia and critical care medicine. This year would include subspecialty time in pediatric cardiology, pulmonology, pain management, and regional anesthesia, and additional time in the neonatal, adult surgical, and pediatric medical, surgical, and cardiac intensive care units. Year 6, the first fellowship year, would be evenly divided between pediatric anesthesia and pediatric critical care medicine (6 months each). Finally, year 7 would be a hybrid year, with 8 months of research and the rest of the time devoted to clinical responsibilities, including call. By developing and defining specific competencies, professional outcome metrics, and serial levels of supervision for both pediatric anesthesia and pediatric critical care medicine programs, this revised program would meet the training requirements of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, the American Board of Pediatrics, and the American Board of Anesthesiology and allow the trainee to be a candidate for board certification in both pediatric anesthesia and pediatric critical care medicine. Further, we believe that the year after completion of this training should be a protected time period, in which institutions that hire these formidably trained individuals should provide them with protected nonclinical time and mentorship in order for them to continue their research and further their faculty development. Because the number of available training positions for the combined 5-year dual training program is limited, and medical students must identify this pathway in their third or the early part of the fourth year of medical school, we believe that our proposed shortened training program can be modified for pediatric residents who choose a career in pediatric anesthesia and critical care medicine during their pediatric residencies. In this paradigm, the combined training program would take 8 rather than 7 years. Years 6 through 8 would be modeled on years 5 through 7, as described above, for those individuals who are in the abbreviated 5-year combined residencies. Because approximately 40%–60% of patients admitted to most pediatric intensive care units are postsurgical, we believe that having a subset of physicians trained in pediatrics and anesthesiology adds significant value to patient care and to the team of physicians and nurses staffing the pediatric intensive care unit. The pediatric critical care anesthesiologist not only can share expertise in airway management, vascular access, pain management, and sedation administration, but can impart his/her experience and understanding of perioperative care. However, once trained, another issue must be addressed: Where will these pediatric anesthesiology intensivists work after their training? Institutions will have to individualize how to incorporate these quadruple-boarded physicians into their coverage and their financial and revenue models. Currently, several successful models of multidisciplinary staffing and financial revenue management exist at some institutions, such as the Johns Hopkins Hospital, the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, the Children’s Hospital of Los Angeles, and the Mayo Clinic. How to incorporate this model into pediatric intensive care units that are administratively managed within departments of pediatrics remains a hurdle that must be overcome or will force many quadruple-boarded, pediatric critical care anesthesiologists away from critical care medicine. Finally, as when one reads a mutual fund prospectus, there is an immediate disclaimer “that past performance is no guarantee of future success.” In terms of professional development, we disagree. Indeed, we believe that past performance is the best predictor of future results. It is no accident that 11 of the past 15 presidents of the Society for Pediatric Anesthesia, the largest specialty society of its kind in the world, with more than 3500 members, were all quadruple-boarded, pediatric critical care anesthesiologists. Indeed, 2 of the next 3 members in line for the presidency of the society were similarly trained. Thus, we contend that not only is it necessary to protect the continuing existence of the pediatric critical care anesthesiologist, but the very survival of our specialty may depend on it. DISCLOSURES Name: Myron Yaster, MD. Contribution: This author helped draft the initial manuscript, critically review the final manuscript, and approved the manuscript as submitted. Name: Peter J. Davis, MD. Contribution: This author helped draft the initial manuscript, critically review the final manuscript, and approved the manuscript as submitted. Name: William J. Greeley, MD. Contribution: This author helped draft the initial manuscript, critically review the final manuscript, and approved the manuscript as submitted. This manuscript was handled by: James A. DiNardo, MD, FAAP.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yaster et al. (2019) conducted an editorial in Pediatric critical care anesthesiology training and workforce. The authors propose a revised 7- to 8-year combined training pathway to preserve the quadruple-boarded pediatric critical care anesthesiologist and ensure the specialty's future.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: