Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The growing shortage of pediatric anesthesiologists in the United States threatens subspecialized care and requires urgent interventions in recruitment, compensation, and training pathways.
The growing workforce shortage of pediatric anesthesiology physicians in the United States threatens the future of subspecialized care for pediatric surgical patients, demanding an urgent reassessment of recruitment, training, and retention strategies. Pediatric anesthesiology manpower is deficient in many countries of the world, although the severity and causation vary by country [1]. For over 10 years, the percentage of unfilled programs in the Pediatric Anesthesiology Fellowship National Resident Matching Program (NRMP) has continued to steadily increase. In 2015, while only 10% of programs were left unfilled, 67.2% did not fill in 2023. There were only 19 programs nationally, which filled every available position, while 39 programs remained unfilled. Voluntary surveys conducted by the Pediatric Anesthesia Leadership Council during the 2023–2024 academic year confirm concerns of an insufficient workforce, finding institutions on average are seeking between 3 and 4 general pediatric anesthesia faculty and one cardiac anesthesia faculty member [2]. There is a critical shortage of fellowship graduates in the United States leading to a significant hiring impetus for pediatric anesthesiology staff nationally, and persistent concerns about the future capacity to meet the increasing demands of subspecialized pediatric anesthesia care. The data on pediatric anesthesiology workforce trends remain somewhat convoluted and require ongoing analysis to clearly elucidate the supply/demand relationship. A 2018 comprehensive workforce analysis by Muffly et al. had previously predicted that the growth in fellows may surpass the growth in the pediatric population and inpatient procedures in the United States from 2015 to 2035 [3]. Contrastingly, Abouleish et al. have concluded a pandemic triggered labor shortage in the anesthesiology workforce due to a number of factors including retirement, changing workload expectations, an emphasis on wellness, and a disruptive expansion of nonoperating room anesthesia sites without a simultaneous increase in anesthesia clinicians [4]. In a similar vein, a more recent analysis of pediatric cardiac anesthesiologists identified that 49.2% of institutions are actively recruiting faculty, a number that may underestimate the demand as the COVID-19 pandemic may have further exacerbated staffing shortages due to dynamic career trajectories [5]. The American Board of Anesthesiology (ABA) survey of residents entering CA training from 2013 to 2016 and followed through graduation indicates that three of five residents intended to pursue fellowship, with pediatric anesthesia, pain medicine, and cardiac anesthesia equally popular, accounting for 20% of fellows each, with pediatric anesthesia choice stable at or above 20% for graduating cohorts in Years 2016–2019. The most recent NRMP data indicate that while the number of pediatric anesthesiology programs remains stable since 2019, at 58 in the last 2023 NRMP Match, the number of positions offered (220 in 2019, and 211 in 2023, but 229 in 2024) is increasing. The number of match applicants, however, had steadily declined from 178 in the 2020 appointment year to 129 for the 2024 appointment year, but increased to 165 in the 2024 Match. Although 40.8% of offered positions went unfilled in the 2023 NRMP Match, in the 2024 San Francisco Match, this ratio decreased to 29.3%, despite the 8.5% increase in the number of positions, perhaps indicating that interest in the subspecialty is increasing [6]. In further support of this conjecture, the latest data indicate that almost 30% more fellows will enter pediatric anesthesia training in 2025 than in 2024; this is not, however, true for adult cardiothoracic anesthesia. We can perhaps understand the complicated over supply of fellowship positions based upon the history of the subspecialty. A survey of pediatric anesthesiology program directors found that graduates from 2008 to 2010 exceeded retiring faculty by 12–1. This, along with a projected decrease in the national pediatric population from 23% to 20% between 2014 and 2060, created concern as to whether the job market could accommodate fellowship graduates [7]. Notwithstanding the projected job market headwinds, a pivotal shift occurred in 2013 when two important events occurred: (1) the ABA first offered the subspecialty certification examination, and (2) the number of training programs offering positions increased. We are now in a period when many more positions are available than potential fellows, likely due to the opportunity cost of sacrificing a lucrative attending position for an extra year of training, competition with subspecialties offering a more favorable work-life balance, and complicated healthcare workforce dynamics. Furthermore, it is conceivable that the prestige of these programs has diminished from repeated years of unfilled spots. It remains challenging to find an attending position with a purely pediatric practice, as many fellowship trained attendings work in a mixed practice. Additionally, the academic positions with a predominantly pediatric caseload remain understaffed and often offer a more challenging lifestyle including longer work hours, lower reimbursement rates, and fewer opportunities for career advancement and scholarly productivity due to less academic time that previously offered. With the COVID-19 pandemic exacerbating decreased fellowship enrollment and the retirement of many Baby Boomer physicians, there is a real risk for pediatric patients no longer being anesthetized by subspecialty-trained pediatric anesthesiologists. Unfortunately, this workforce shortage is contemporaneous with an increasing volume of high-acuity, complex pediatric patients that mandate subspecialized pediatric anesthetic care. To compound the staffing shortage, economic pressures from commercial and governmental payers have forced dental, endoscopy, bronchoscopy, nuclear medicine, radiologic imaging and interventional radiology procedures to be conducted not only outside the operating room but also in outpatient settings [3]. While efforts to optimize patient safety and outcomes dating to the 1950s reduced the anesthesia-related mortality for healthy children to close to zero, progress does not extend to children with an ASA physical status ≥ 4 (mortality 0.1–1.2 per 10 000 anesthetics) [2]. Improved pediatric outcomes are due to a sophisticated network of safety science research and implementation including medications, equipment, human factor analysis, professional standardization, regionalization, and high-quality subspecialty training. The literature has previously shown a lower rate of perioperative adverse events when care is provided by a trained pediatric subspecialist for children with comorbid conditions under the age of 2 [5]. Alas, to ensure adequate clinical coverage in both inpatient and outpatient settings, the care of healthy, older, and routine pediatric cases is often delegated to nonsubspecialty trained anesthesiologists. To ensure the delivery of high-quality, safe pediatric anesthesia care, we must ensure that adequately trained anesthesiologists continue to lead the advanced perioperative management of high-risk infants and children and do not relinquish this role to nonphysician anesthesia providers. There are a number of strategies that can be implemented to improve our pediatric anesthesiology fellowship crisis in the United States. Firstly, financial incentivization via increased compensation both during and after fellowship can help assuage concerns about both an additional year of training and a lower starting salary than some general anesthesiologists. Higher signing bonuses and fellowship stipends could be utilized to alleviate the financial stress of trainees and be more competitive with attending level salaries. Second, the importance of work-life balance to our millennial and Gen Z trainees cannot be understated, accomplished by employers offering reduced work hours, encouraging a more manageable case-load, and providing access to wellness resources. Unfortunately, this represents a chicken and egg type of problem, as only with more subspecialized pediatric anesthesiology attendings can we improve the subspecialty's lifestyle. Third, improved national awareness and advocacy regarding the impending staffing crisis is mandatory to stimulate interest in maintaining the high standard of perioperative outcomes for high-acuity pediatric patients and increasing the prestige of the field. Professional anesthesia organizations should launch concerted, collaborative campaigns with pediatric organizations to highlight the positive impact of subspecialty training on favorable perioperative outcomes. Fourth, streamlined training pathways via combined or integrated residency-fellowship models may be warranted to reduce residency length of training and attract residents. These streamlined pathways could include expedited dual certification in pediatric anesthesiology and critical care or cardiac, early specialization tracks for those interested in the field, accelerated fellowship programs, and modular learning fellowship programs. Fifth, as with any field, early and strong mentorship remains integral to providing guidance on career development and reiterating the benefits of a career in pediatric anesthesiology, including lower burnout rates, higher job satisfaction, and positive working relationships with surgeons and operating room staff. Sixth, a collaborative pediatric anesthesiology task force, utilizing the Delphi methodology, recently recommend some changes to fellowship programs: a standardized national curriculum with more rigorous didactic standards, an updated case log system, and a standardized toolkit for summative and formative assessments of future fellows [8]. Addressing the pediatric anesthesiology fellowship crisis in the United States will require a concerted effort amongst leaders in the field, regulatory bodies, medical institutions, and professional organizations to entice residents to pursue a career in the subspecialty. An improved, innovative compensation structure at the residency and attending level, targeted mentorship, enhanced early exposure, and competency-based, streamlined training pathways are integral to curbing the workforce crisis. The putative cause of the shortage and recommendations proposed in this article could be germane to the workforce shortage in other countries. By implementing these strategies, we can ensure the field remains a sustainable option for trainees while maintaining the highest standard of care for our most vulnerable pediatric patients. The data that support the findings of this study are available on request from the corresponding author. The data are not publicly available due to privacy or ethical restrictions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Salik et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: