Why the study?
To review the influence of the Ross procedure's historical context on its dissemination and implementation.
What factors influenced the dissemination and implementation of the Ross procedure in adults?
What factors influenced the dissemination and implementation of the Ross procedure in adults?
The historical failure of the Ross procedure to gain widespread acceptance was likely due to imperfect implementation and technical complexity rather than a lack of efficacy, suggesting current guidelines may need updating.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Should not yet change Ross procedure practice; leaves open whether targeted implementation strategies could improve adoption.
Background: The science of dissemination and implementation (D&I) aims to improve the quality and effectiveness of care by addressing the challenges of incorporating research and evidence-based practice into routine clinical practice. This lens of D&I has challenged the interpretation and incorporation of data, noting that failure of a given therapy may not reflect lack of efficacy, but instead reflect an imperfect implementation. The aim of this manuscript is to review the influence of the Ross procedure's historical context on its D&I. Methods: A contextual baseline of the Ross procedure was defined from the procedure's original description in the literature to major publications since the 2017 valvular heart disease guidelines. D&I evaluation was conducted using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR), using constructs from each of the five respective domains to define the main determinants. Results: Each of the five CFIR domains appears to be correlated with a factor influencing the Ross procedure's varied history of enthusiasm and acceptance. The complex nature of Ross required adaptation for optimization, with a strong correlation of center volume on outcomes that were not considered in non-contemporary studies. Outcomes later published from those studies influenced social and cultural contexts within the aortic surgery community, and led to further organizational uncertainty, resulting in slow guideline incorporation. Conclusions: The D&I of the Ross procedure was a result of inadequate appreciation of technical complexity, effect of patient selection, and complex aortic surgery experience, resulting in dismissal of an efficacious procedure due to a misunderstanding of effectiveness.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bilodeau et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: