Why the study?
Do wearable heart rate monitors accurately measure heart rate compared to electrocardiography during common training movements in tactical populations?
Do wearable heart rate monitors accurately measure heart rate compared to electrocardiography during common training movements in tactical populations?
Chest straps and armbands provide more accurate continuous heart rate monitoring than wrist-worn devices during physical training, and should be preferred when precise heart rate training is necessary.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Chest straps may support accurate HR monitoring during dynamic training; hypothesis-generating and should not yet change practice pending larger ECG-validated studies.
Heart rate samples (n = 4500–8000) from wearables were compared to electrocardiography during a steady-state ruck (Ruck-S), maximal effort ruck (Ruck-M), submaximal cycle (Cycle), and Tabata Circuit. One device was worn at each location (wrist: Polar Grit-X, Garmin Fenix 6; chest-straps: Polar H10, Garmin HRM-Pro; armband: Polar Verity). Comparisons were made via percent error (MAPE) ≤5%, Concordance Correlation Coefficient (CCC), and ordinary least product regressions (OLP). H10 demonstrated strong agreement for all movements (MAPE = 1.28–3.40%, CCC = 0.93–0.99). During Ruck-S, Ruck-M, and Cycle, HRM-Pro (MAPE = 1.96–3.73%, CCC = 0.95–0.99) and Verity (MAPE = 1.84–5.36%, CCC = 0.98–0.99) demonstrated strong agreement. Fenix-6 demonstrated low MAPE (4.23–5.44%) and moderate to strong CCC (0.76–0.96) for Ruck-S, Ruck-M, and Cycle, while Grit-X had poor agreement (MAPE = 8.49–16.45%; CCC = 0.24–0.78). Tabata Circuit had the worst disagreement for all devices. Overall, chest straps and armbands demonstrated the strongest agreement, and should be worn when precise heart rate training is necessary.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Merrigan et al. (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: