Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Feminist Studies 46, no. 2. © 2020 by Feminist Studies, Inc. 459 Elizabeth Currans Transgender Women Belong Here: Contested Feminist Visions at the Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival The stories we tell about feminism matter. Clare Hemmings’s exploration of how feminists describe feminist history demonstrates the ease with which we create linear narratives of loss and progress that obscure the complexity of both current and past theories and practices .1 Similarly, Finn Enke explores the risks of adhering to plausible narratives about transgender women: such accounts fit understandings of transsexuality developed by psychiatric gatekeepers that transgender people were expected to construct in order to access medical transition. In requesting that contemporary feminists reject similarly coherent narratives , Enke critiques accounts that assume trans-exclusion was inherent to 1970s feminism. In particular, Enke asks, “How did ‘1970s feminism ’ enter collective memory as the exclusionary thing, distinct from the experiences, labor, and critiques by feminists of color, trans and queer people of the same era? And why, when existing nuanced narratives might invite us to deeper analysis, are stories of exclusion and abjection so magnetic? More to the point, how might we highlight the mixings in the past and simultaneously envision a less polarized present?”2 1. Clare Hemmings, Why Stories Matter: The Political Grammar of Feminist Theory (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2011). 2. Finn Enke, “Collective Memory and the Transfeminist 1970s: Toward a Less Plausible History,” TSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly 5, no. 1 (2018): 10. 460 Elizabeth Currans This is not a call to ignore the violent and exclusionary rhetoric of some prominent figures, but rather, it is an invitation to contextualize those voices within a larger, multifaceted milieu. This article jumps off from a related point, asking what it would look like to apply insights from Hemmings, Enke, and other historically minded feminist thinkers to twenty-first-century feminism by focusing on one of the most controversial and long-lasting lesbian feminist events, the Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival (MichFest). This festival was considered by many to be an iconic radical lesbian feminist holdout against social and scholarly shifts in conversations about feminism, gender, and women. I explore some of the negotiations and conflicts about gender that occurred there, especially the organizing by a group called Transgender Women Belong Here (TWBH), because doing so provides an opportunity to explore and embrace a more complicated story about feminists—cisgender, transgender, and otherwise. Transgression of gender norms was both embraced and rejected at MichFest, but contemporary narratives about it stress its exclusionary practices. By examining the complexity of feminist and queer ideas present at MichFest in its final years, we can explore the ways that even at a site identified with a rigid understanding of lesbian feminist separatism, feminism remained complex and contested well into the twenty-first century. Developing less plausible narratives about MichFest can help us better understand our recent feminist past and, hopefully, support more inclusive, empathetic feminist futures. On the Importance of Stories (Or, Methodology) Existing research about MichFest examines the festival’s history, geographies , importance for lesbian culture, and controversies about transgender inclusion.3 An emerging scholar-activist conversation explores 3. Bonnie J. Morris, Eden Built by Eves: The Culture of Women’s Music Festivals (Los Angeles: Alyson Books, 2000); Boden C. Sandstrom, “Performance, Ritual, and Negotiation of Identity in the Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival ” (PhD diss., University of Maryland, College Park, 2002), https://search .proquest.com/docview/288028308/abstract/85FF2A738A6C47FDPQ/1; Kath Browne, “Womyn’s Separatist Spaces: Rethinking Spaces of Difference and Exclusion,” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 34, no. 4 (2009): 541–56; Kath Browne, “Lesbian Separatist Feminism at Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival,” Feminism & Psychology 21, no. 2 (2010): 248–56; Laurie J. Elizabeth Currans 461 ways of claiming trans-inclusive versions of lesbian feminism.4 Building from this work and that of theorists such as Hemmings and Enke, I seek to tell a complex story about a feminist institution frequently depicted as one-dimensional in order to think differently about MichFest and early twenty-first-century feminism. As Hemmings demonstrates, linear narratives emphasizing either feminist progress away from an exclusionary past or the loss of a more radical feminist past...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elizabeth Currans (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: