Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The potential roles of care, compassion, and related altruistic emotions in civic action have been continually defended in recent years against the Stoic and Kantian focus on deemphasizing or reducing emotion in moral reason. We find such views in calls for certain kinds of multicultural education, citizenship education for "compassionate globalization," and education for understanding (and combating) white privilege. 2 However, defenders of emotions concede that they can play fleeting, or even harmful, roles in shaping altruistic moral action, without restraint or appropriate judgment. Emotional learning can also lead students to take a step back and turn away, in confusion, anger, guilt, or fear. Even when emotional learning and development is aligned with educators' aims, the actions that emotions motivate may be ineffective, or worse, may not lead to positive social change, and/or may lead students to take a cynical perspective. aiming to revise models of global citizenship against the backdrop of neoliberal society and globalization, it is worth reconsidering a kind of rational, less emotional or unemotional altruism and/or care as a global educational virtue. This essay defends limited, rational altruism, elaborated as non-relational care, as a virtue of global citizenship. First, I compare rational altruism favorably to defenses of the necessary involvement of emotional motivations such as compassion and care toward altruistic action. I then elaborate "non-relational" care (by which I mean a care that is not justified in terms of particular interpersonal relations) as a duty in the international arena that entails skills or cognitive capacities rather than (or prior to) affect. I conclude by briefly applying the argument for a less emotional, less relational altruism or care to education for sustainable development, as people often develop feelings for the planet, but perhaps to their detriment, since they lack a foundation of skills for systemic environmental action.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Liz Jackson (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: