Analysis shows variance in primitive coprime count using Möbius decomposition, indicating empirical trends.
Hardy conjectured that the classical Gauss circle error satises E(x) = O(x1/4+ε) for every ε>0. This paper analyses a related quantity: the uctuation ER(x) = N(x)−x/(2π) in the primitive coprime count N(x) at a single scale. We show that ER admits an exact Möbius decomposition into 2ω(s) fractional-part terms, where ω(s) is the number of distinct prime factors of s= m+ n. For prime s, this reduces to two terms with constant variance. For composite s, we identify the per-s variance formula Var(e|s) = A(s)/12*φ(s)/s+Var(T)/4 , A(s) = 2^ω(s) +1−Prod p|s (1 +1/p^2) , empirically, with no free parameters; a rigorous derivation is open. By the HardyRamanujan theorem (ω(s)∼log log s), this gives σc ∼(ln s)^(ln 2)/2, conrmed numerically to <1% error from x= 10^8 to 10^17. The growth of σc is consistent with an ε-type correction within ER at a single scale, conditional on (i) the empirical formula above and (ii) pairwise decorrelation across s (not proved in this series). No implication for the classical Gauss circle conjecture E(x) = O(x1/4+ε) is established here: the Möbius shell expansion linking ER to E transfers quarter-power bounds only when ε>1/4, and the regime ε→0+ of Hardy's conjecture lies outside this range. The present paper makes no claim toward Hardy's ε.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arno Wilhelmsen (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: