Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this report, we show that theechinoderm microtubule (MT)-associated protein (EMAP) and relatedEMAP-like proteins (ELPs) share a similar domain organization with a highly conservedhydrophobic ELP (HELP) domain and a large tryptophan-aspartic acid (WD) repeat domain. To determine the function of mammalian ELPs, we generated antibodies against a 70-kDa human ELP and showed that ELP70 coassembled with MTs in HeLa cell extracts and colocalized with MTs in the mitotic apparatus. To determine whether ELP70 bound to MTs directly, human ELP70 was expressed and purified to homogeneity from baculovirus-infected Sf9 cells. Purified ELP70 bound to purified MTs with a stoichiometry of 0.40 ± 0.04 mol of ELP70/mol of tubulin dimer and with an intrinsic dissociation constant of 0.44 ± 0.13 μm. Using a nucleated assembly assay and video-enhanced differential interference contrast microscopy, we demonstrated that ELP70 reduced seeded nucleation, reduced the growth rate, and promoted MT catastrophes in a concentration-dependent manner. As a result, ELP70-containing MTs were significantly shorter than MTs assembled from tubulin alone. These data indicate that ELP70 is a novel MT destabilizer. A lateral destabilization model is presented to describe ELP70's effects on microtubules. In this report, we show that theechinoderm microtubule (MT)-associated protein (EMAP) and relatedEMAP-like proteins (ELPs) share a similar domain organization with a highly conservedhydrophobic ELP (HELP) domain and a large tryptophan-aspartic acid (WD) repeat domain. To determine the function of mammalian ELPs, we generated antibodies against a 70-kDa human ELP and showed that ELP70 coassembled with MTs in HeLa cell extracts and colocalized with MTs in the mitotic apparatus. To determine whether ELP70 bound to MTs directly, human ELP70 was expressed and purified to homogeneity from baculovirus-infected Sf9 cells. Purified ELP70 bound to purified MTs with a stoichiometry of 0.40 ± 0.04 mol of ELP70/mol of tubulin dimer and with an intrinsic dissociation constant of 0.44 ± 0.13 μm. Using a nucleated assembly assay and video-enhanced differential interference contrast microscopy, we demonstrated that ELP70 reduced seeded nucleation, reduced the growth rate, and promoted MT catastrophes in a concentration-dependent manner. As a result, ELP70-containing MTs were significantly shorter than MTs assembled from tubulin alone. These data indicate that ELP70 is a novel MT destabilizer. A lateral destabilization model is presented to describe ELP70's effects on microtubules. microtubule(s) microtubule-associated protein echinoderm MT-associated protein EMAP-like protein hydrophobic ELP 70-kDa human EMAP-like protein 1,4-piperazinediethanesulfonic acid phosphate-buffered saline restrictedly overexpressed proliferation-associated protein video-enhanced differential interference contrast microscopy tryptophan-aspartic acid Cell motility, cell morphogenesis, spindle formation, and chromosome movements require the dynamic turnover of microtubules (MTs).1 This non-equilibrium behavior is an intrinsic property of MTs driven by the irreversible hydrolysis of tubulin-liganded GTP and the structural polarity of the tubulin heterodimer (1Desai A. Mitchison T.J. Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol. 1997; 13: 83-117Google Scholar, 2Margolis R.L. Wilson L. Bioessays. 1998; 20: 830-836Google Scholar). Individual MTs can switch between extended periods of slow growth and rapid shrinkage. The transitions between these two states, known as catastrophe and rescue, are quite sudden and are believed to be stochastic events (3Walker R.A. O'Brien E.T. Pryer N.K. Soboeiro M.F. Voter W.A. Erickson H.P. Salmon E.D. J. Cell Biol. 1988; 107: 1437-1448Google Scholar, 4Horio T. Hotani H. Nature. 1986; 321: 605-607Google Scholar). This dynamic behavior of MTs is best described by the dynamic instability model and is generally associated with the behavior of MT plus-ends nucleated at the centrosome (5Mitchison T. Kirschner M. Nature. 1984; 312: 237-242Google Scholar, 6Mitchison T. Kirschner M. Nature. 1984; 312: 232-237Google Scholar). MT dynamics in living cells are highly regulated. For example, MTsin vivo polymerize more rapidly and undergo more frequent catastrophe and rescue events than do MTs assembled from pure tubulinin vitro (7Cassimeris L. Cell Motil. Cytoskeleton. 1993; 26: 275-281Google Scholar). These results indicate that there are cellular factors that regulate individual parameters of MT dynamics (1Desai A. Mitchison T.J. Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol. 1997; 13: 83-117Google Scholar). In addition to having cell type or tissue specific factors (8Shelden E. Wadsworth P. J. Cell Biol. 1993; 120: 935-945Google Scholar), the cell must regulate the activity of each factor during cell division (9McNally F.J. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 1996; 8: 23-29Google Scholar, 10Andersen S.S. Trends Cell Biol. 2000; 10: 261-267Google Scholar), during cell differentiation (11Bulinski J.C. Gundersen G.G. Bioessays. 1991; 13: 285-293Google Scholar), and within different regions of the cell (12Wadsworth P. Cell Motil. Cytoskeleton. 1999; 42: 48-59Google Scholar). Recently, several proteins that destabilize MTs have been characterized. In yeast, Kar3 is a minus-end-directed kinesin that localizes to spindle poles in vivo and destabilizes MTs at their minus ends in vitro (13Endow S.A. Kang S.J. Satterwhite L.L. Rose M.D. Skeen V.P. Salmon E.D. EMBO J. 1994; 13: 2708-2713Google Scholar, 14Saunders W. Hornack D. Lengyel V. Deng C. J. Cell Biol. 1997; 137: 417-431Google Scholar). Op18/stathmin is a low molecular weight tubulin-binding protein that destabilizes MTs in tissue culture cells (15Marklund U. Larsson N. Gradin H.M. Brattsand G. Gullberg M. EMBO J. 1996; 15: 5290-5298Google Scholar) and in Xenopus egg extracts (16Belmont L.D. Mitchison T.J. Cell. 1996; 84: 623-631Google Scholar). XKCM1, a member of the Xenopus Kin I kinesin family, promotes catastrophes by favoring a conformational change at the MT ends that leads to protofilament peeling and MT shortening (17Walczak C.E. Mitchison T.J. Desai A. Cell. 1996; 84: 37-47Google Scholar, 18Desai A. Verma S. Mitchison T.J. Walczak C.E. Cell. 1999; 96: 69-78Google Scholar). Katanin uses the energy of ATP hydrolysis to sever MTs at the centrosomes (19McNally F.J. Thomas S. Mol. Biol. Cell. 1998; 9: 1847-1861Google Scholar, 20Hartman J.J. Mahr J. McNally K. Okawa K. Iwamatsu A. Thomas S. Cheesman S. Heuser J. Vale R.D. McNally F.J. Cell. 1998; 93: 277-287Google Scholar). It is clear that several proteins with different modis operandi destabilize MTs in the cell. One of the most abundant microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) in dividing sea urchin embryos is the echinoderm MT-associated protein (EMAP) (21Keller 3rd, T.C. Rebhun L.I. J. Cell Biol. 1982; 93: 788-796Google Scholar, 22Suprenant K.A. Marsh J.C. J. Cell Sci. 1987; 87: 71-84Google Scholar, 23Vallee R.B. Bloom G.S. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 1983; 80: 6259-6263Google Scholar). EMAP is a 75-kDa, WD repeat protein with little sequence similarity to other well-characterized MAP families (24Li Q. Suprenant K.A. J. Biol. Chem. 1994; 269: 31777-31784Google Scholar, 25Suprenant K.A. Tuxhorn J.A. Daggett M.A. Ahrens D.P. Hostetler A. Palange J.M. VanWinkle C.E. Livingston B.T. Dev. Genes Evol. 2000; 210: 2-10Google Scholar). In early embryos, EMAP localizes to the MTs of the first cleavage mitotic apparatus where it is hyperphosphorylated (26Bloom G.S. Luca F.C. Collins C.A. Vallee R.B. Cell Motil. 1985; 5: 431-446Google Scholar, 27Suprenant K.A. Dean K. McKee J. Hake S. J. Cell Sci. 1993; 104: 445-450Google Scholar, 28Brisch E. Daggett M.A. Suprenant K.A. J. Cell Sci. 1996; 109: 2885-2893Google Scholar). Although the function of EMAP in cells is unknown, its evolutionary conservation suggests that it plays an important role in MT assembly and function in a variety of cells (25Suprenant K.A. Tuxhorn J.A. Daggett M.A. Ahrens D.P. Hostetler A. Palange J.M. VanWinkle C.E. Livingston B.T. Dev. Genes Evol. 2000; 210: 2-10Google Scholar). Here, we characterize a 70-kDa human EMAP-like protein (ELP70), show that it is a novel MT destabilizer, and suggest that it is an important regulator of MT dynamics during the cell cycle. HeLa cells (American Type Culture Collection) were cultured at 37 °C in 5% CO2 with Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium/F-12 Hams' plus 2 mm l-glutamine, 10% fetal bovine serum (Invitrogen), 10,000 units/ml (1670 units/mg) penicillin, and 10 mg/ml streptomycin. Paclitaxel (Taxol) was a gift of the Drug Synthesis and/Chemistry Branch, Developmental Therapeutics Program, Division of Cancer Treatment, NCI, National Institutes of Health. GTP (tetralithium salt) was purchased from Roche Molecular Biochemicals and was stored as a stock solution in distilled water at −80 °C. Monoclonal anti-β-tubulin (TUB 2.1) was from the Sigma Chemical Corp. Cy2- and Cy3-conjugated donkey anti-mouse and rabbit secondary antibodies were from Jackson ImmunoResearch Laboratories, Inc. ELP70 was expressed as a 6His fusion protein in baculovirus-infected Sf9 cells. The full-length ELP70 coding sequence was inserted into theKpnI and NdeI restriction sites of the baculovirus transfer vector pAcHLT-C (BD PharMingen Inc.). Sf9 insect cells were transfected with this construct and the linearized baculovirus generated by were as individual that were and of Sf9 cells. Sf9 cell were at by in 10 and The was at and was purified from the by and Inc.). 6His ELP70 was by into mm mm mm The of ELP70 was was purified to homogeneity from bovine by of MT assembly by Suprenant K.A. 1993; Scholar, J. 1988; Scholar). MTs were at °C by the addition of to a of μm. A constant of MTs was with ELP70 in mm GTP and MTs were at and ELP70 was from as described Purified the protein been by a assay was as an on the were with of ELP70 in the of of the was with a and Institutes of at To the of ELP70 the each protein was to and by the molecular of The behavior of individual MTs nucleated from was video-enhanced differential interference contrast microscopy as described L. J. Cell Biol. 1994; Scholar). The was at 37 °C with an and the were to a to data were during the A with and was to individual The from a a a interference and and a and were with a and were by a and were with a and with the by of MT growth and shortening were by a For protein an ELP70 was into of the vector and was transfected into the J.J. Scholar). the expressed protein were and on a antibodies were generated against the ELP70 Inc.). antibodies were by K. Mitchison T.J. Walczak C.E. 1998; Scholar). purified were in and and to J. Cell Biol. 1993; Scholar). was in mm mm and the as described K. Mitchison T.J. Walczak C.E. 1998; Scholar), antibodies were with or in were into with a in and stored at °C. MTs were assembled and purified from of HeLa cells as described R.B. Collins C.A. 1986; Scholar). HeLa cells were in 2 of a that mg/ml 10 mg/ml 2 mg/ml mg/ml mg/ml mg/ml and mm The was at 10 at 2 °C. The was and the was at at 2 °C. Paclitaxel and GTP were to the at a of and The was to 37 °C and on The was to a and with 10% and mm MTs were the by at at 2 °C. MT proteins were by and HeLa cells were with in at cells were in and with in and cells were in antibodies into with at 37 °C. with the antibodies were or donkey anti-mouse or secondary antibodies in at 37 °C were in and on in a solution of 10% and 5% For microscopy, cells were with a and were on were and were with Inc.). of an ELP70 generated a ELP70 that was to a human cell Inc.). were on with G. J. Mol. Biol. Scholar). were and by the For known ELP70 were on the were from to H. T. J. Scholar), with and by with secondary antibodies Inc.). was by the acid assay bovine serum as a The protein (EMAP) is a member of a of (ELPs) in and at In there are EMAP-like proteins and The the first EMAP-like protein in was from the at M. M.D. J. 1997; Scholar). The role by in is at this are believed to be the and of this S.J. Scholar, D. S. J. P. J. P. A. J. M.D. Nature. Scholar). ELP70 was and by to sea urchin EMAP and is the most similar to sea urchin EMAP Palange J.M. Suprenant K.A. 1999; Scholar), sequence and sequence similarity the of the in is the member of the ELP in is the full-length of the there are and in or was as protein is overexpressed during M. 2000; Scholar). In addition to the human ELPs, are the the sea the and the A of ELP a highly acid domain that with an a and This (HELP) domain is between human and sea urchin and been in other known This of conservation ELP that the domain is to be to ELP For example, a that the of sea urchin the is MT in vitro Ahrens D.P. Q. Suprenant K.A. Cell Motil. Cytoskeleton. Scholar). The of ELP70 is in the and Although there is sequence between this and the known MT of other and have been in J. Cell Biol. Scholar). In of the ELP share a to the repeat domain of and S.A. 1988; Scholar, J. Biol. Chem. 1991; Scholar). the the is in the ELP of the ELP70 is of a of that the of a WD repeat domain WD are in a variety of proteins with and The of the of the that a WD repeat a of a C. K. Trends Sci. 1999; Scholar). to ELP70 into an ELP70 is expressed in a variety of from a on chromosome To determine ELP70 was expressed in human cell we a with a to the of ELP70 The ELP70 a in HeLa and cells. The ELP70 to a in and that there be of ELP70 The was in and cells at These results are in of the in human the is in and Palange J.M. Suprenant K.A. 1999; Scholar). This the that ELP70 is in cells. ELP70 were abundant in HeLa we antibodies generated against a expressed ELP70 fusion protein to determine ELP70 proteins were associated with HeLa ELP70 antibodies a with a molecular with the ELP70 and the or To determine whether HeLa ELP70 was an HeLa MTs were by The in that the 70-kDa ELP70 was in the MT and in the These results are with the ELP70 an protein in HeLa cells. ELP70 is associated with MTs in the antibodies were to the of ELP70 in dividing HeLa cells. The presented in show that ELP70 was in the of the mitotic spindle apparatus. To determine whether ELP70 bound to a fusion protein was purified from baculovirus-infected Sf9 insect cells and with MTs Purified ELP70 bound to purified bovine In similar ELP70 in the of or in the of The results of several with a constant of MTs that ELP70 bound to MTs in a concentration-dependent manner. these an was ELP70 to bovine MTs was at a stoichiometry of 0.40 ± 0.04 mol of ELP70/mol of tubulin dimer and the intrinsic dissociation constant ELP70 to MTs was to be 0.44 ± 0.13 μm. This of that ELP70 the of the MT In of this we that ELP70 bound to MT The of ELP70 with MTs as with an of shorter MTs by with a To the of ELP70 on MT dynamics in individual MTs nucleated from were by As in seeded was the ELP70 The of MTs from the plus-ends of individual was reduced from an of ± MTs where of to ± MTs and ± MTs The in seeded was at of In addition to seeded nucleation, MT were shorter In the of more than of the MTs were shorter than with and MTs a of μm. these of ELP70 and there were MTs that be of ELP70 to the MTs were and to data in the of catastrophe or of growth microtubule and catastrophes at the plus-ends of tubulin tubulin tubulin ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± 2 ± ± ± ± ± in a Individual parameters of dynamic instability as the and shortening as as catastrophe and rescue were at As in I and ELP70 effects on the dynamic behavior of The was reduced significantly in the of of For example, the addition of ELP70 to tubulin significantly reduced the from ± to ± the of ELP70 from to in an in the from ± to ± The in the was concentration-dependent and was more at a tubulin of where the addition of ELP70 the from ± to ± In contrast to the effects on ELP70 to have little on the of microtubule dynamics at the of tubulin ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± in a These effects on the were specific to the plus-ends of the MTs at the in the and of ELP70 ELP70 the from a MT to shortening MT in a concentration-dependent manner. For example, in the of ELP70 and catastrophes were catastrophes in of with catastrophe tubulin catastrophes in of This is a in the catastrophe in the catastrophe was the MTs as Although the of catastrophe at the and of MTs in the of there was on the shortening at the or In there was on the from a shortening MT to a MT at the at these tubulin the to the and rescue events were the of rescue be Although a rescue events were at the it is that to be in the of To MT proteins important in have dividing as mammalian cells in or sea urchin than two several abundant MT-associated proteins (MAPs) were in HeLa cells and as that with MTs of MT assembly and J.C. G.G. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. Scholar, J.A. R.B. Scholar). The most abundant HeLa in this were the J.C. J. Scholar) and the of D. J. Cell Biol. 1993; J.C. A. J. Cell Sci. 1994; 107: Scholar). the of these the Rebhun in an abundant MAP from sea urchin mitotic (21Keller 3rd, T.C. Rebhun L.I. J. Cell Biol. 1982; 93: 788-796Google Scholar). This to was the echinoderm it was the most abundant MAP in sea and K.A. Dean K. McKee J. Hake S. J. Cell Sci. 1993; 104: 445-450Google Scholar). In this report, we show that an is in HeLa cells and that this protein is an MT that localizes to the mitotic apparatus. The of sequence similarity ELP that of the ELP have similar of the data indicate that ELP have we show that ELP70 is an MT-associated In sea and MTs in vitro and in vivo K.A. Dean K. McKee J. Hake S. J. Cell Sci. 1993; 104: 445-450Google Scholar) and sea urchin EMAP been to the assembly dynamics of MTs in vitro L. Suprenant K.A. J. Biol. Chem. 1998; with MTs and is expressed in K. E. M. Suprenant K.A. Mol. Biol. Cell. 2000; Scholar). In human is overexpressed during J.C. G.G. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. Scholar), and ELP is as an abundant protein in ELP70 is an protein as demonstrated by in vitro MT of ELP70 with HeLa and of ELP70 to the mitotic apparatus. In vitro of MT dynamics in the and of ELP70 that ELP70 is an MT destabilizer. nucleated assembly ELP70 generated and shorter MTs with with tubulin by catastrophes and by the of MTs at their plus For example, at ELP70 reduced the from to at the effects at the the of catastrophe at the The was that MTs assembled in the of ELP70 were shorter than assembled from tubulin alone. In there were of MT nucleated from in the of urchin EMAP and mammalian ELP70 in their effects on MT The most is that MTs assembled in the of EMAP are than MTs assembled from tubulin L. Suprenant K.A. J. Biol. Chem. 1998; Scholar), and MTs assembled in the of ELP70 are significantly shorter The in MT in the of EMAP is by a to in the at the In sea urchin EMAP the of the of rescue at the For example, at a tubulin of were in at the tubulin in the of L. Suprenant K.A. J. Biol. Chem. 1998; Scholar). In ELP70 a of rescue at the and little on the of rescue at the at the tubulin in the assay of ELP70 and were and of were it is that ELP70 rescue sea urchin EMAP and mammalian ELP70 MTs in a concentration-dependent manner. urchin EMAP to MTs with a stoichiometry of mol of EMAP mol of tubulin dimer with an intrinsic dissociation constant of Ahrens D.P. Q. Suprenant K.A. Cell Motil. Cytoskeleton. Scholar). In this we show that human ELP70 the MT sites at a of mol of ELP70 mol of tubulin dimer with an intrinsic dissociation constant of 0.44 μm. The data of EMAP and ELP70 are on the of and it is to suggest that have different sites on the were in the to characterize sea urchin EMAP and human it is these to the in their effects on MT For example, sea urchin EMAP is as in an as human MT assembly in the of sea urchin EMAP L. Suprenant K.A. J. Biol. Chem. 1998; Scholar) were at of EMAP to tubulin than were the ELP70 In the effects of human ELP70 on bovine tubulin assembly was at 37 °C a to a sea urchin EMAP was purified from a that at a of effects on MT dynamics were at a that the assembly of tubulin EMAP L. Suprenant K.A. J. Biol. Chem. 1998; Scholar). Although these assay have the results it is more that EMAP and of the ELP have with different effects on MT and A molecular of the of ELP70 and proteins each ELP70 MTs were shorter to the effects of the and the catastrophe are driven by GTP hydrolysis M.F. D. C. D. Scholar, S. N. Mitchison T.J. Mol. Biol. Cell. Scholar) and are with the of protofilament as the MT rapidly E. R.A. J. Cell Biol. 1991; Scholar, E. J. Cell Biol. 2000; Scholar). shortening structural and transitions that at the MT ends (1Desai A. Mitchison T.J. Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol. 1997; 13: 83-117Google E. Annu. Rev. 2000; Scholar). For example, Op18/stathmin is to MT at the by GTP hydrolysis Larsson N. Gullberg M. L. Mol. Biol. Cell. 1999; 10: Scholar). It is clear from the model of an MT that GTP hydrolysis by the have little on the lateral of the at the minus ends E. M. R.A. Cell. 1999; 96: Scholar). effects on the plus-ends are with this In catastrophes at and ends in the of GTP hydrolysis A. Verma S. Mitchison T.J. Walczak C.E. Cell. 1999; 96: 69-78Google Scholar). the of the MT with MT with to change from a to a These results indicate that can a conformational change in the tubulin a ELP70 destabilize MTs by a The stoichiometry of to MTs that ELP70 the of the than the MT This that it is that ELP70 results in a at the or of the It is that ELP70 the catastrophe by tubulin For this to be mol of ELP70 to more than mol of tubulin dimer to a tubulin that in a similar at ELP70 at the in the of catastrophe be In ELP70 the growth at the and the have been that was the These data a structural and we that ELP70 destabilizes MTs by an of ELP70 with the tubulin in we that ELP70 to the MT its domain and that this domain to the lateral between and as a that the between the and the E. Annu. Rev. 2000; Scholar, E. M. R.A. Cell. 1999; 96: Scholar). These lateral between tubulin are during MT For example, or that the of the MT to the lateral between R.A. T.C. Mol. Biol. Cell. 1994; 5: Scholar, 3rd, E. J. Biol. Chem. 2000; Scholar). the lateral are the ends of the into their M.F. D. a that the peeling of a MT E. R.A. J. Cell Biol. 1991; Scholar, Rev. Scholar, Salmon E.D. J. Cell Sci. 96: Scholar). In ELP70 a conformational change in the tubulin dimer that the of the extended protofilament associated with MT growth H.P. J. Cell Biol. Scholar, J. Mol. Biol. Scholar, D. E. J. Cell Biol. Scholar). that MTs assembled in the of ELP70 have at the plus-ends and ELP70 the at the MT The this is in to be more there is GTP at the of the MT R.A. Salmon E.D. J. Cell Biol. 1997; Scholar). there are structural that indicate that the lateral are at the are than the E. M. R.A. Cell. 1999; 96: Scholar). In addition to these ELP70 the by to the the are at the ELP70 the at this These are the cell ELP70 is in the of the mitotic a that that ELP70 have an function during It is to that ELP70 is in the in MT dynamics and in MT that during the from to G.G. J. Cell Sci. 1994; 107: Scholar, G.G. J. Cell Biol. 1996; Scholar). the of catastrophe and the of rescue as cultured mammalian cells Wadsworth P. Mol. Biol. Cell. Scholar). In this ELP70 be the factor the change in the catastrophe In ELP70 alone. have that ELP70 destabilizes the lateral protofilament in an and in ELP70 an MT rapid in with other (15Marklund U. Larsson N. Gradin H.M. Brattsand G. Gullberg M. EMBO J. 1996; 15: 5290-5298Google Scholar, L.D. Mitchison T.J. Cell. 1996; 84: 623-631Google Scholar, C.E. Mitchison T.J. Desai A. Cell. 1996; 84: 37-47Google Scholar, 18Desai A. Verma S. Mitchison T.J. Walczak C.E. Cell. 1999; 96: 69-78Google Scholar, F.J. Thomas S. Mol. Biol. Cell. 1998; 9: 1847-1861Google Larsson N. Gullberg M. L. Mol. Biol. Cell. 1999; 10: Scholar). ELP70 MT dynamics in vivo is an important
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Eichenmüller et al. (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: