Key result
Heart Sure A320 shows no nadir SpO2 difference vs Masimo Rad-5, unlike Nonin and BioBeat.
Why the study?
With an increasing number of portable pulse oximetry devices of varying designs and specifications, this study evaluated the accuracy of three portable devices against a reference standard during 6-minute walk tests.
Do portable oximetry devices accurately measure SpO2 compared to a reference standard during 6-minute walk tests in patients with cardiac or respiratory diseases?
Observational (n=50)
Do portable oximetry devices accurately measure SpO2 compared to a reference standard during 6-minute walk tests in patients with cardiac or respiratory diseases?
The Heart Sure A320 and Nonin Wrist-Ox 2 3150 portable oximeters provide comparable nadir SpO2 measurements to a reference standard during 6-minute walk tests, supporting their potential use for remote monitoring.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Heart Sure A320 agrees with reference nadir SpO2 in 6MWT; leaves open accuracy of other portables and clinical adoption.
Background: Pulse oximetry is a common technique used to measure S pO 2 , with increasing numbers of portable devices of different designs and technical specifications. This study examined accuracy of commercial and medical-grade portable oximetry devices (BioBeat wristwatch, Nonin WristOx 2 3150, and Heart Sure A320) in measuring S pO 2 compared with the reference standard (Masimo Rad-5) during 6-min walk tests (6MWTs). Methods: This prospective study included 50 subjects, with 10 recruited for each of the five target groups, including COPD, interstitial lung disease, pulmonary hypertension, oxygen therapy users, and other cardiac/respiratory diseases. All subjects underwent 6MWT using the reference standard and the three test oximetry devices. Accuracy was measured by comparing mean nadir S pO 2 . Subjects were asked to rate their preference for different oximetry devices at test completion. Results: In contrast to the Masimo, the Nonin had lower nadir and mean S pO 2 (P ≤ .001 for both), with higher measurements for the BioBeat ( P < .001 for both) and no differences for the Heart Sure ( P = .18 for nadir S pO 2 , P = .96 for mean S pO 2 ). Time spent at S pO 2 ≤ 88 was higher for the Nonin (70%, P < .001) but lower for the Heart Sure (58%, P < .001), compared with the Masimo (64%). There were no significant differences observed in peak heart rate measurements between the Masimo with the Nonin and BioBeat ( P < .05 for both), with lower measurements using the Heart Sure ( P < .001). The BioBeat was most preferable amongst subjects ( n = 31), with all test oximeters having high patient satisfaction (mean \7-point Likert scale scores of 6–7). Conclusion: The Heart Sure A320 and Nonin Wrist-Ox 2 3150 had comparable performance in detecting nadir S pO 2 within a mean difference of 3% in comparison with the Masimo Rad-5, with potential use for remote monitoring.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marshall et al. (2025) conducted an observational in COPD, interstitial lung disease, pulmonary hypertension, oxygen therapy users, and other cardiac/respiratory diseases (n=50). BioBeat wristwatch, Nonin WristOx 2 3150, and Heart Sure A320 vs. Masimo Rad-5 was evaluated on Mean nadir SpO2 (p=P=.18 (Heart Sure), P≤.001 (Nonin), P<.001 (BioBeat)). The Heart Sure A320 portable oximeter showed no significant difference in nadir SpO2 compared to the Masimo Rad-5 reference, while the Nonin and BioBeat devices differed significantly.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: