Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The mass spectrometric analysis of protein phosphorylation is still far from being routine, and the outcomes thereof are often unsatisfying. Apart from the inherent problem of substoichiometric phosphorylation, three arguments as to why phosphorylation analysis is so problematic are often quoted, including (a) increased hydrophilicity of the phosphopeptide with a concomitant loss during the loading onto reversed-phase columns, (b) selective suppression of the ionization of phosphopeptides in the presence of unmodified peptides, and (c) lower ionization/detection efficiencies of phosphopeptides as compared with their unmodified cognates. Here we present the results of a study investigating the validity of these three arguments when using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. We utilized a set of synthetic peptide/phosphopeptide pairs that were quantitated by amino acid analysis. Under the applied conditions none of the experiments performed supports the notions of (a) generally increased risks of losing phosphopeptides during the loading onto the reversed-phase column because of decreased retention and (b) the selective ionization suppression of phosphopeptides. The issue of ionization/detection efficiencies of phosphopeptides versus their unphosphorylated cognates proved to be less straightforward when using electrospray ionization because no evidence for decreased ionization/detection efficiencies for phosphopeptides could be found. The mass spectrometric analysis of protein phosphorylation is still far from being routine, and the outcomes thereof are often unsatisfying. Apart from the inherent problem of substoichiometric phosphorylation, three arguments as to why phosphorylation analysis is so problematic are often quoted, including (a) increased hydrophilicity of the phosphopeptide with a concomitant loss during the loading onto reversed-phase columns, (b) selective suppression of the ionization of phosphopeptides in the presence of unmodified peptides, and (c) lower ionization/detection efficiencies of phosphopeptides as compared with their unmodified cognates. Here we present the results of a study investigating the validity of these three arguments when using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. We utilized a set of synthetic peptide/phosphopeptide pairs that were quantitated by amino acid analysis. Under the applied conditions none of the experiments performed supports the notions of (a) generally increased risks of losing phosphopeptides during the loading onto the reversed-phase column because of decreased retention and (b) the selective ionization suppression of phosphopeptides. The issue of ionization/detection efficiencies of phosphopeptides versus their unphosphorylated cognates proved to be less straightforward when using electrospray ionization because no evidence for decreased ionization/detection efficiencies for phosphopeptides could be found. Protein phosphorylation is one of the most prevalent intracellular protein modifications that is of pivotal importance in numerous cellular processes including cell differentiation, proliferation, and migration. It is estimated that ∼30% of all proteins in a cell are phosphorylated at any given time. However, this number is in stark contrast to the actual number of phosphorylation sites found so far. For instance, the Phospho.ELM database (phospho.elm.eu.org) currently lists 1703 experimentally verified phosphorylation sites for 556 different proteins derived from eukaryotes, the human protein reference database (www.hprd.org) lists 3652 reported phosphorylation sites on 1240 human proteins, and PhosphoSite (www.phosphosite.org) lists 6084 non-redundant phosphorylation sites on 2430 human and mouse proteins. However, a recent study by Beausoleil et al. (1Beausoleil S.A. Jedrychowski M. Schwartz D. Elias J.E. Villen J. Li J. Cohn M.A. Cantley L.C. Gygi S.P. Large-scale characterization of HeLa cell nuclear phosphoproteins.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 2004; 101: 12130-12135Google Scholar) gave some idea about the expected number of phosphorylation in the cell when the authors performed a large scale phosphoproteomics study on HeLa cell nuclei. Although their method was biased against basic phosphopeptides where His, Lys-Pro, and/or Arg-Pro residues are in close proximity to the phosphoamino acid residue, more than 2000 phosphorylation sites on 967 nuclear proteins were found. Considering the fact that protein phosphorylation analysis is of major interest in numerous laboratories around the world it is surprising that more information about protein phosphorylation sites has not been gathered since the discovery of protein phosphorylation. This raises the question as to why it is still such a challenge to perform unbiased protein phosphorylation analysis. One inherent reason is the generally low phosphorylation stoichiometry of most of the proteins such that phosphopeptides are grossly underrepresented in the generated complex peptide mixtures (see below). In addition, numerous reasons can be listed for not being able to identify and localize a phosphorylation site in a given protein, which affects all stages of phosphorylation analysis, i.e. sample preparation, analysis, and data interpretation. Examples for problems during the sample preparation include e.g. omission of phosphatase inhibitor, overestimation of the degree of phosphorylation because of the lack of information about the phosphorylation stoichiometry when using phosphospecific antibodies, and/or underestimation of the heterogeneity of the phosphorylation due to nonspecific 32P-labeling. However, even if it was ensured that a particular protein sample is phosphorylated by using other methods such as radiolabeling it is often the case that the mass spectrometric analysis does not provide any information about the sites of phosphorylation. Three main reasons are commonly used to explain as to why the phosphopeptides were missed during the mass spectrometric analysis: (i) increased hydrophilicity and hence reduced retention of phosphopeptides on reversed-phase materials, (ii) selective suppression of their ionization/detection efficiencies in the presence of large amounts of unphosphorylated peptides, and (iii) lower detection efficiencies of phosphopeptides as compared with their unphosphorylated cognates. In this study we tried to scrutinize these different arguments often brought forward with the aim to draw the attention to the most prevalent problem(s) of mass spectrometric phosphorylation analysis and to improve the analysis where it is most fruitful/promising. All solvents used were of HPLC-grade quality from Burdick and Jackson (VWR International). All chemicals were purchased from Sigma unless otherwise noted. The synthetic peptides were HPLC-purified and quantitated in duplicate by amino acid analysis. Stock solutions were prepared using freshly calibrated pipettes. The phosphopeptide and its unphosphorylated counterpart were mixed in at least two different defined ratios (final concentrations 30–150 nm). To avoid carry-over problems during the LC/MS analyses, the solutions of two different peptide pairs were analyzed in an alternating fashion. The standard protein digest was prepared by digesting 50 μm protein solution overnight at 37 °C using sequencing grade trypsin (w/w 1:10, Roche Biochemicals). All electrospray ionization experiments were performed using a QSTAR XL hybrid mass spectrometer (AB/MDS Sciex) hyphenated with microscale capillary reversed-phase HPLC (Famos autosampler (LC Packings), Agilent 1100 HPLC pump (Agilent)). The columns were packed in-house using Magic C18 (5 μm, 200 Å, Michrom BioResources) beads. The buffer compositions are as follows: buffer A: 2.5% acetonitrile, 0.2% formic acid; buffer B: 2.5% H2O, 0.2% formic acid. For the quantitation experiments a 5-min gradient was used with mass spectra being acquired every 0.15 s. Data analysis and quantitation was done using the Analyst software package provided by Applied Biosystems/MDS Sciex. “Phosphopeptides often are lost during the loading onto the reversed-phase columns because the addition of anionic/acidic phosphate groups increases hydrophilicity resulting in reduced retention.” This is one reason often used to explain why a phosphorylation analysis using LC/MS failed. To test this we used a set of peptide/phosphopeptide pairs that varied in length from 7 to 17 amino acids, resembling the size of peptides commonly observed in tryptic digests. Cysteine and methionine-containing peptides were not included in this study to avoid problems associated with partial oxidation. All peptide pairs were analyzed using water/acetonitrile/0.2% formic acid buffers as mobile phases and Magic C18 as stationary phase; Magic C18 is a reversed-phase material commonly used in proteomics applications. Interestingly, despite the common belief that phosphopeptides are more hydrophilic than their unphosphorylated cognate, all singly phosphorylated peptides tested eluted off the reversed-phase column after the unmodified complement irrespective of the number of basic amino acid residues (His, Lys, Arg; Table I). One example is presented in Fig. 1A; it shows the selected ion chromatograms (XICs) 1The abbreviation used is: XIC, selected ion chromatogram. of RNYSVGS and RNYpSVGS Table I, Peptide species 2), the shortest peptide/phosphopeptide pair investigated. Although there is a considerable overlap in the elution profiles, the phosphopeptide clearly elutes after the unphosphorylated cognate. Of the three doubly phosphorylated peptides in this test set, two phosphopeptides eluted significantly later than the singly phosphorylated or unphosphorylated peptide from the reversed-phase column; one example is shown in Fig. 1B. The third doubly phosphorylated peptide with the sequence DQAVpTEpYVATR Table I, Peptide species 27) was the only peptide whose modified form eluted before its unmodified complement (Fig. 1C). It was noted that this particular peptide was the only phosphopeptide in our sample set in which the number of phospho moieties exceeded the number of basic amino acid residues. This led us to hypothesize that phosphorylation does increase the hydrophilicity of peptides; however, if the peptide contains basic amino residues that are positively charged under standard LC(MS) conditions, the increase of hydrophilicity can be overcompensated by charge neutralization, i.e. reduction of the net charge, thereby reducing the overall hydrophilicity.Table ITest peptidesPeptide speciesPeptide sequenceZΔRTIon./detec. efficiency ratiomin1LLLRLpSENSG2++ 0.11.4 (0.13)2RNYpSVGS2++ < 0.051.08 (0.074)3IVADQpTPTPTRF2++ < 0.050.28 (0.021)4FDSLPSpSPSSATPH2++ < 0.051.74 (0.099)5GAHFpSVSSLAE2++ 0.31.7 (0.034)6IGRRQpSLIEDA2++ < 0.050.50 (0.038)73++ < 0.050.86 (0.078)8KTQApSQGTLQTR2++ 0.150.082 (0.006)93++ 0.150.64 (0.076)10LQRQPSSpSPGPTPR2++ < 0.050.93 (0.067)113++ < 0.053.02 (0.12)12LRLSSpSSGRLR2++ 0.10.37 (0.031)133++ 0.10.59 (0.043)14GLGTRTGpSNLDRDKL2++ 0.150.65 (0.053)153++ 0.150.84 (0.093)164++ 0.15650 (320)17KFELLPpTPPLSPSRRSG3++ 0.11.6 (0.24)18KDLKRLFpSGTQISTI2++ 0.250.99 (0.066)193++ 0.251.7 (0.086)204++ 0.25850 (600)21SRARIGpSDPLAYEPK2++ 0.10.79 (0.038)223++ 0.10.88 (0.14)234++ 0.1100 (10)24RYPRPVpSVPPSPSLSR3++ 0.250.52 (0.064)25KRRQIpSIRGIV2++ 0.250.35 (0.031)263++ 0.250.76 (0.028)27DQAVpTEpYVATR2+− 0.152.0 (0.20)28KFELLPpTPPLpSPSRRSG (P vs. ppP)3++ 0.182.3 (0.27)29RYPRPVpSVPPpSPSLSR (P vs. ppP)3++ 0.550.79 (0.088)30KFELLPpTPPLpSPSRRSG (pP vs. ppP)3++ 0.081.5 (0.15)31RYPRPVpSVPPpSPSLSR (pP vs. ppP)3++ 0.31.5 (0.17) Open table in a new tab This means that the introduction of phosphorylation sites can decrease the overall hydrophilicity/increase the retention time under the employed LC conditions as long as the positive net charge decreases. Once the number of phosphorylation sites exceeds the number of basic residues the hydrophilicity increases again whereby the most hydrophobic species are generated when the number of phosphoamino acid residues equals the number of basic amino acid residues, i.e. a net charge of 0 is reached. The hypothesis of charge compensation gained support when the doubly phosphorylated peptide DQAVpTEpYVATR Table I, Peptide species 27) was partially dephosphorylated and the mixture of doubly phosphorylated, singly phosphorylated, and unphosphorylated species was analyzed by LC/MS. The selected ion chromatograms (XIC) of the different species are shown in Fig. 1C. Whereas the doubly phosphorylated peptide (net charge −1) eluted before the unphosphorylated peptide (net charge +1), the singly phosphorylated peptide (net charge 0) eluted after the unphosphorylated peptide. The described elution order can be observed in the absence of strong ion pairing reagents such as trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) as these agents mask the positive charges on peptides, whereas the negative charges on peptides caused by carboxylic groups are neutralized at acidic pH. This is contrasted by peptides with highly acidic functional groups such as phospho moieties for which one negative charge on the phosphate group remains even at pH 2 such that phosphopeptides elute before their unphosphorylated peptide counterparts when ion pairing reagent is present to neutralize the positive charges. Because strong ion pairing reagents such as TFA are often not required (and not desired) in LC/MS experiments the elution order of phosphopeptides and their unmodified cognates are easily modulated. More systematic work is necessary to evaluate the effects of different stationary phases and buffer compositions on the elution order of peptides and their phosphorylated cognates. This notion is underscored by a recently published example of a doubly phosphorylated peptide and its partially phosphorylated/unphosphorylated cognates; in this example, which employed only formic acid without TFA in the LC buffers, the peptides eluted in the following order: monophosphopeptide A < diphosphopeptide < unmodified peptide < monophosphopeptide B (2Ballif B.A. Roux P.P. Gerber S.A. MacKeigan J.P. Blenis J. Gygi S.P. Quantitative phosphorylation profiling of the ERK/p90 ribosomal S6 kinase-signaling cassette and its targets, the tuberous sclerosis tumor suppressors.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 2005; 102: 667-672Google Scholar). Such an elution order is to irrespective of the presence or absence of any ion pairing the data presented clearly that phosphorylation does not to an overall increase in This is of particular interest for tryptic peptides, which peptides with at least one basic amino acid such that singly phosphorylated peptides elute after the unphosphorylated this the of losing phosphopeptides during the loading of the reversed-phase however, can to decreased retention if the number of phosphorylation sites is not by the number of basic amino acid residues. However, because phosphorylation affects the of sites to the site of phosphorylation A. D. of protein phosphorylation by a of and loss mass it can be expected that phosphorylated peptides an increased of more than one basic amino acid residues, partially this be which (a) increase the number of basic residues the peptides and/or (b) increase the length of the peptides, which generally increases the retention reducing the loss of phosphopeptides during the loading of the reversed-phase the loss of phosphopeptides because of increased hydrophilicity can be a problem if nonspecific are used peptides without any basic amino acid residues. This notion was when a highly acidic and hydrophilic peptide/phosphopeptide pair with the sequence was analyzed by whereas the unmodified form of the peptide was on the C18 the phosphorylated was in the under standard LC/MS species are in the presence of unmodified is often used that is without of this To test the validity of this for amounts of synthetic phosphopeptides and their unphosphorylated cognates were mixed with amounts of a tryptic from to The ratios of the of peptide versus phosphopeptide were for pair and are shown in Fig. It is from the that there is no in the ionization/detection efficiencies with of unmodified To that this is not only for this particular set of and tryptic set of different pairs was tryptic digest of numerous and a mixture This mixture the digest of a The ratios for the different peptide/phosphopeptide pairs present in are shown in Fig. The of all again shows that the ratios of peptide versus phosphorylated not significantly irrespective of the of the i.e. irrespective of the number of unmodified peptides with the species of This is in Fig. which mass spectra at the elution of one of the synthetic test peptides with an tryptic in the sample at the time of elution are The in of the two of experiments not support the notion that selective suppression of phosphopeptides when analyzed by electrospray ionization mass in the presence of unmodified spectra at the elution of the synthetic test peptides digests. A synthetic peptide with an was at a tryptic digest digest digest and digest of an mixture of and the of the peptides were and it was found that were by the presence of a large of unphosphorylated peptides the This is shown in Fig. where the ion and the for one peptide/phosphopeptide versus pair in the presence of low amounts of digest and in the presence of of digest are The are in the time for For no loss in was i.e. none of the experiments described supports the notion of selective ionization suppression of phosphopeptides in the presence of unmodified peptides when the sample by LC/MS. It be noted that only of low and were and the of ionization was not reached. To test the issue of selective ionization suppression of phosphopeptides under ionization conditions, i.e. the number of charges is and the are for the peptide/phosphopeptide pairs were a of tryptic digest not expected the of the peptides and the phosphopeptides were significantly However, no selective suppression of the phosphorylated species as compared with the unphosphorylated was i.e. the results of this not support the notion of selected suppression of phosphorylated species even under ionization It be however, that the phosphopeptides are by the suppression observed for all unmodified and/or modified peptides of under the conditions of phosphopeptides in complex peptide mixtures such as cell not be because there is such a large number and of unmodified peptides that it is that a phosphopeptide be the most and/or i.e. species that are under ionization This means that the most for the analysis of phosphopeptides from complex mixtures selective of the phosphopeptides. “Phosphopeptides lower ionization/detection efficiencies than their unphosphorylated is one of the most commonly used arguments for not phosphopeptides in a particular i.e. protein digests. This notion is on the idea that the phosphate group of phosphorylated species is thereby the ionization and detection efficiencies under acidic conditions used for mass spectrometric experiments in positive ion To this phosphopeptides lower efficiencies than their unphosphorylated the synthetic peptides and phosphopeptides used for the experiments described were by HPLC to to amino acid analysis in for Stock solutions of all peptides were prepared using freshly calibrated to the of which to systematic peptide/phosphopeptide pair was mixed in at least two different defined ratios before electrospray ionization mass spectrometric capillary HPLC was used to the the mass Magic C18 was used for the LC experiments because this reversed-phase material is a commonly used stationary in the of The buffers used were the as described To the ionization/detection efficiencies for the peptide/phosphopeptide selected ion chromatograms were generated for observed charge of every peptide/phosphopeptide the under the were using the quantitation in Analyst were for the defined ratios from to The ratios of the ionization/detection efficiency for the different peptide/phosphopeptide the the ionization/detection efficiency for peptide versus phosphopeptide is such that a number that the unphosphorylated peptide has a ionization/detection whereas a a ionization/detection efficiencies for the phosphorylated A mass spectrometer was used for the This of mass spectrometer has a However, problems are for by the provided by the which for the of the ionization/detection efficiency ratios the of by The results of this set of experiments are listed in Table I, column The peptides are for the number of basic amino acid residues and number of phosphorylation The of the experiments can be as follows: More phosphopeptides species ionization/detection efficiencies than their unphosphorylated cognates as compared with the This is more when the peptide contains more than one basic amino acid the phosphopeptides with only one basic amino acid which as such tryptic peptides ionization/detection efficiencies versus from to Table I, Peptide species of the peptide pairs ionization/detection efficiencies in the of However, it is not from the which peptide to ionization/detection efficiency phosphorylation. This the lack of of the ionization/detection efficiencies of The ionization/detection efficiency unphosphorylated peptide versus phosphopeptide increases with the charge The of however, The observed increases varied from Table I, Peptide species and to about Table I, Peptide species and One example is presented in Fig. which shows charge of to of the peptide Table I, Peptide species that the peptide/phosphopeptide were in a A decrease of the phosphopeptide ion to the unphosphorylated form is with charge Although the number of doubly phosphorylated peptides is to draw any about their ionization/detection efficiencies as compared with their unphosphorylated it is still to that all three test peptides ionization/detection efficiencies to of the singly phosphorylated in the one case where the number of phosphorylation sites is than the number of basic amino acid residues Table I, Peptide species the ionization/detection efficiency of peptide versus phosphopeptides is only It was observed that for the three highly basic peptides, the most highly charged species of the unmodified ionization/detection efficiencies 2 to of than the phosphorylated complement species and One example is given in Fig. The charged phosphopeptide Table I, Peptide species is more and than the unmodified However, the charged unmodified species shows a ionization/detection efficiency as compared with its phosphorylated which is A of the of these species this charge because of the overall of the as the is reduced by e.g. phosphorylation, and the ion of this charge The large standard in these from the of the used for the The in this of the study clearly a that phosphopeptides lower ionization/detection efficiencies than their unphosphorylated does not to electrospray ionization mass as the of the phosphopeptides tested ionization/detection efficiencies than their unphosphorylated cognates. ionization/detection efficiencies were found for peptides, i.e. with only one basic amino acid This is by other from our and other which ionization/detection efficiencies for tryptic peptide/phosphopeptide i.e. peptides that were generated by tryptic of proteins M. and quantitation of protein phosphorylation stoichiometry by Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 2005; 102: A for and quantitation of phosphopeptides by mass for the degree of phosphorylation at sites in 2004; all these ionization/detection efficiencies for tryptic peptides and their unphosphorylated cognates. This raises the the lack of the ionization/detection efficiencies of been published investigating the of different of peptides on the ionization/detection efficiencies during electrospray a positive the and the ionization/detection efficiencies of peptides as as and ionization/detection efficiencies electrospray from retention the of tryptic peptides in mass spectrometry. A 2004; S.A. ionization of protein solution pH and protein 2004; Scholar). However, when following their of that the phosphorylated form of a particular peptide lower ionization/detection efficiencies than their unmodified because the and are to decrease with the of a phosphate Although the of a peptide is reduced phosphorylation, the of phosphorylation on the is not as described some of charge decrease the hydrophilicity of basic amino peptides in formic solutions phosphorylation. However, a more of the of the ionization/detection efficiencies of peptides still has to be Such a study include the of the peptides as as and the of the The importance of the was underscored by a phosphorylation analysis on the performed in our The sample was analyzed The following were varied in the two LC/MS (i) a different electrospray was and (ii) the LC buffer was from acid to water/acetonitrile/0.2% formic acid. the of the to the phosphopeptide and its unmodified it was noted that the charged species ratios for of conditions, whereas the of the charged peptide/phosphopeptide is significantly from to (Fig. It be noted that ionization/detection efficiencies of peptides and their phosphorylated cognates is not only of importance in the of this study can be used for quantitation of protein phosphorylation as we recently shown M. and quantitation of protein phosphorylation stoichiometry by Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 2005; 102: Scholar). Once such an ionization/detection efficiency has been the degree of phosphorylation can easily be on the ion by the ionization/detection Because there is a lack of information the ionization/detection the ratios to be However, it is that this can be estimated in the a of ionization/detection efficiencies has been This the of quantitation of protein phosphorylation The data presented in this study some onto some of the often used reasons why mass spectrometric phosphorylation analysis is so The reasons included the issue of increased hydrophilicity because of phosphorylation, the of selective suppression of phosphopeptides in the presence of unphosphorylated peptides, and the lower ionization/detection efficiencies of phosphopeptides as compared with their unphosphorylated cognates. A set of synthetic peptide/phosphopeptide pairs was to and quantitated by amino acid analysis. peptide/phosphopeptide pairs were used for numerous mass spectrometric which one to these could be from the results of these
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Steen et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: