Key result
Novel 2D echo method matches 3D accuracy for LV mass and improves reproducibility over 1D.
Why the study?
Increased left ventricular mass predicts adverse cardiovascular events, but conventional echocardiographic methods are limited by poor reproducibility and accuracy.
Does a novel 2D echocardiography method improve the reproducibility and accuracy of left ventricular mass quantification compared to conventional methods?
Cohort (n=85)
No
Does a novel 2D echocardiography method improve the reproducibility and accuracy of left ventricular mass quantification compared to conventional methods?
A novel 2D echocardiographic method for quantifying left ventricular mass provides better reproducibility and accuracy than conventional 1D methods, with accuracy comparable to 3D echocardiography.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support LV mass quantification by novel 2D echo; hypothesis-generating and requires prospective validation before practice change.
Increased left ventricular mass (LVM) is a strong independent predictor for adverse cardiovascular events, but conventional echocardiographic methods are limited by poor reproducibility and accuracy. We developed a novel method based on adding the mean wall thickness from the parasternal short axis view, to the left ventricular end-diastolic volume acquired using the biplane model of discs. The participants (n = 85) had various left ventricular geometries and were assessed using echocardiography followed immediately by cardiac magnetic resonance, as reference. We compared our novel two-dimensional (2D) method to various conventional one-dimensional (1D) and other 2D methods as well as the three-dimensional (3D) method. Our novel method had better reproducibility in intra-examiner [coefficients of variation (CV) 9% vs. 11-14%] and inter-examiner analysis (CV 9% vs. 10-20%). Accuracy was similar to the 3D method (mean difference ± 95% limits of agreement, CV): Novel: 2 ± 50 g, 15% vs. 3D: 2 ± 51 g, 16%; and better than the "linear" 1D method by Devereux (7 ± 76 g, 23%). Our novel method is simple, has considerable better reproducibility and accuracy than conventional "linear" 1D methods, and similar accuracy as the 3D-method. As the biplane model forms part of the standard echocardiographic protocol, it does not require specific training and provides a supplement to the modern echocardiographic report.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kristensen et al. (2022) conducted a cohort in Patients scheduled for echocardiography with various left ventricular geometries (n=85). Novel 2D echocardiography method for left ventricular mass quantification vs. 3D echocardiography and 1D echocardiography (CMR as reference) was evaluated on Accuracy of left ventricular mass quantification compared to cardiac magnetic resonance (mean difference in grams). A novel 2D echocardiographic method for quantifying left ventricular mass showed similar accuracy to 3D echocardiography and better reproducibility than 1D methods.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: