Key result
iSpO2 shows moderate validity for resting SpO2 and good validity for pulse rate vs traditional oximeters.
Why the study?
Does the iSpO2 pulse oximeter provide valid measurements of resting SpO2 and pulse rate compared to a traditional pulse oximeter in healthy adults?
Observational (n=30)
No
Does the iSpO2 pulse oximeter provide valid measurements of resting SpO2 and pulse rate compared to a traditional pulse oximeter in healthy adults?
The iSpO2 pulse oximeter demonstrates moderate validity for SpO2 and good validity for pulse rate compared to traditional pulse oximetry, supporting its use for short-term resting measurements.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support short-term resting use in healthy adults; leaves open validation in clinical populations.
Context: Pulse oximetry has become mobile with the use of smartphone and Bluetooth wireless technology. This technology offers many benefits but has not been extensively studied. There is a need to further validate its clinimetric properties for health professionals to provide proper guidance to patients. Objective: This investigation assessed the concurrent validity of the iSpO 2 pulse oximeter against a traditional pulse oximeter in measuring short-term resting blood oxygen saturation (SpO 2 ) and pulse rate. Design: Observational study of reliability. Setting: University kinesiology laboratory. Participants: Thirty healthy, recre-ationally active adults (18 men, 12 women; mean age = 25.7 ± 5.46 years, mean height = 170.3cm ± 9.51, mean body mass = 76.4 kg ± 19.33). Intervention: Resting measurement of SpO 2 and pulse rate using the iSpO 2 pulse oximeter with the iPad Mini and a traditional pulse oximeter with Bluetooth. Main Outcome Measure: Resting SpO 2 and pulse rate were concurrently measured over 5 min. Results: The concurrent validity between the iSpO 2 and traditional pulse oximeter was moderate for measuring SpO 2 , intraclass correlation coeffcient (ICC)(3, 1) = .73, SEM = 0.70%, and good for pulse rate, ICC(3, 1) = .97, SEM = 1.74 beats per minute (bpm). The minimal detectable change at the 95% confidence interval for both instruments suggests that there may be 1.94% disagreement for SpO 2 and 4.82 bpm disagreement between pulse oximetry methods. The 95% limits of agreement (LoA) for measuring SpO 2 suggests that the iSpO 2 and traditional pulse oximeters may vary -0.28 ± 1.98%, or approximately 2%. The 95% LoA for measuring pulse rate suggests that the iSpO 2 and traditional pulse oximeter may vary 1.74 ± 4.98 bpm, potentially upward of 6 bpm. On the basis of the results of the LoA, it appears that there may be a slight systematic bias between the two devices, with the traditional pulse oximeter producing higher pulse rates than the iSpO 2 . Conclusion: The findings suggest that both instruments may be beneficial for indirect short-term measurements of resting SpO 2 and pulse rate.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cheatham et al. (2014) conducted an observational in Healthy (n=30). iSpO2 pulse oximeter with iPad Mini vs. Traditional pulse oximeter with Bluetooth was evaluated on Resting SpO2 and pulse rate (ICC 0.73 for SpO2, ICC 0.97 for pulse rate). The iSpO2 pulse oximeter demonstrated moderate concurrent validity for measuring resting SpO2 and good validity for pulse rate compared to a traditional pulse oximeter.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: