Key result
Exercise-induced ST changes for detecting CAD had 85% sensitivity and 100% specificity in patients with normal resting ECGs, but decreased to 76% and 79% in those with abnormal ECGs not on drugs.
Why the study?
Does a maximum graded treadmill exercise test accurately detect coronary artery disease in patients with abnormal control electrocardiograms compared to those with normal control electrocardiograms?
Observational (n=178)
Does a maximum graded treadmill exercise test accurately detect coronary artery disease in patients with abnormal control electrocardiograms compared to those with normal control electrocardiograms?
Exercise-induced ST changes are highly valid for diagnosing CAD in patients with normal resting ECGs or abnormal ECGs without non-nitrate drug therapy, but lose diagnostic utility in patients with abnormal ECGs taking other cardiovascular drugs.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Exercise ST changes warrant cautious use with abnormal resting ECGs; leaves open prospective validation of accuracy.
To determine the validity and safety of exercise induced ST changes (1 mm ischemic depression or further depression in ECG lead V 5 ) as an indication of coronary artery disease (CAD) in patients with abnormal control electrocardiograms (ECG), 121 such patients were compared to 57 patients with a normal control ECG. All underwent a maximum graded treadmill exercise test and coronary arteriography. Among those patients with normal control ECGs, there were no false positives and five false negatives (sensitivity-85%, specificity-100%). In 61 patients with abnormal ECG (no drug therapy except nitrates) there were four false positives and nine false negatives (sensitivity-76%, specificity-79%). In this group of patients T waves reverted from negative to positive in four patients with CAD and 10 patients with no CAD, but T inversion during exercise only occurred in those with CAD (6 patients). Three of 12 patients (25%) with ECG evidence of old infarction and four of eight with single vessel disease had false negative tests. In 60 patients with abnormal ECG on drug therapy there were 10 false positives (17%) and 15 false negatives (sensitivity-55%, specificity-63%). Not helpful in differentiation were resting T vs ST changes, induction of arrhythmias or exercise induced chest pain. The validity of exercise induced ST changes in differentiating CAD is excellent when the control ECG is normal and is only slightly reduced with control ST-T wave abnormalities. When the latter occur in association with cardiovascular drug therapy, other than nitrates, the exercise ECG is of no use in differential diagnosis although still valid and safe for the determination of exercise tolerance.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Linhart et al. (1974) conducted an observational in Coronary artery disease (n=178). Maximum graded treadmill exercise test vs. Normal control ECG was evaluated on Sensitivity of exercise-induced ST changes for coronary artery disease. Exercise-induced ST changes for detecting CAD had 85% sensitivity and 100% specificity in patients with normal resting ECGs, but decreased to 76% and 79% in those with abnormal ECGs not on drugs.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: