Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Recently in these pages, a paper by Lynch appeared in response to a report showing that his numbers for biosynthetic costs (ATP demand) in cells are inflated, so much so that they would require E. coli to obtain >100 ATP per glucose and mitochondria to obtain >240 ATP per glucose. The inflated estimates trace to one factor: Lynch exclusively considers ATP demand and systematically neglects ATP supply—the essence of bioenergetics. Thermodynamics stipulate that a cell cannot grow if its ATP demands exceed its ATP supply. Here I compare Lynch's calculated ATP demands to laboratory measurements of the ATP supply that E. coli synthesizes during cell division. The results bear out my case, and leave no doubt: Lynch's calculations require E. coli to synthesize ~120 ATP per glucose, which is thermodynamically impossible. As a consequence, his demand-only ‘energetic’ attacks on mitochondria and endosymbiosis in evolution are baseless. • The significance of mitochondria in evolution was recently challenged in these pages. • The challenge hinges on calculations for ATP demand in E. coli and other cells. • The calculations are flawed, addressing ATP demand only, ignoring ATP supply. • The flawed calculations would require E. coli to synthesize 120 ATP per glucose. • Obtaining 120 ATP per glucose is not possible, the challenge is baseless.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Martin (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: