Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
ABSTRACTThis article examines how and to what extent ethnic diversity underpinned intergovernmental relations (IGR) in deeply divided societies like India. Central to this is the vertical and intermediating roles of political actors, structures and processes of Indian federalism in defining the ways in which ethnic diversity is territorially managed. Unlike Canada or Belgium which have more formal and robust structures of IGR, the inconsequential roles of formal structures of IGR in India unduly leverage centralizing actors, structures and processes in the territorial management of ethnic diversity. Given that these centralizing actors, structures and processes are contingent on political expediency, the dynamic ideas, interests and strategies of centralizing and regionalist actors are particularly salient in defining not only the contours and outcomes of IGRs but also the ways in which "unity in diversity" are negotiated and balanced within the overarching framework of "self-rule and shared rule." AcknowledgmentsThis article began as a draft for presentation at a conference on "Intergovernmental Relations in Divided Societies" at the Institute for Comparative Federalism, Eurac Research, Bolzano, Italy during 26–29 March 2020. I thank Yonatan Fessha and his team for their kind invite; K.K. Kailash, the two anonymous referees and Anthony Cerulli, the editor of IR for their very insightful and helpful comments. I deeply appreciate the patience and understanding shown by the editorial team of IR as the revisions to this article got over-delayed owing to the illness and demise of my mother. I dedicate this article to my mother, who would have been pleased to see this in print.Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1 See Daniel J. Elazar, Exploring Federalism (Tuscaloosa, AL: The University of Alabama Press, 1987), Michael Burgess, Comparative Federalism: Theory and Practise (New York: Routledge, 2006), Ronald L. Watts, Comparing Federal Systems (Kingston: Queens University Press, 2008, third edition), Alaign-G. Gagnon, The Case for Multinational Federalism. Beyond an All-Encompassing Nation (New York. Routledge, 2010).2 Jan Erk and Lawrence Anderson, "The Paradox of Federalism: Does Self-Rule Accommodate or Exacerbate Ethnic Divisions?" Regional and Federal Studies 19, no. 2 (2009): 191–202.3 Eric Nordlinger, Conflict Regulation in Divided Societies (Cambridge, MA: Harvard Center for International Affairs, 1972).4 William H. Riker, Federalism: Origin, Operation, Significance (Boston: Little Brown, 1964).5 Charles D. Tarlton, "Symmetry and Asymmetry as Elements of Federalism: A Theoretical Speculation," The Journal of Politics 27, no. 4 (1965): 861–74.6 Valerie Bunce, "Federalism, Nationalism and Secession: The Communist and Postcommunist Experience," in Ugo M. Amoretti and Nancy Bermeo (eds.), Federalism and Territorial Cleavages (Baltimore and London: The John Hopkins University Press, 2004).7 Svante E. Cornell, "Autonomy as a Source of Conflict: Caucasian Conflicts in Theoretical Perspective," World Politics 54, no.1 (2002): 245–76.8 Henry E. Hale, "Divided We Stand: Institutional Sources of Ethnofederal State Survival and Collapse," World Politics 56, no. 1 (2004): 165–93.9 Philip G.Roeder, "Ethnofederalism and the Mismanagement of Conflicting Nationalisms," Regional and Federal Studies 19, No. 2, 2009: 203–19.10 For a helpful distinction between "integration" and "accommodation" framework see John McGarry and Brendan O'Leary, "Introduction: The Macro-Political Regulation of Ethnic Conflict," in John McGarry and Brendan O'Leary (eds.), The Politics of Ethnic Conflict Regulation (New York: Routledge, 1993): 1–40. The integration framework is favorable to granting distinctive cultural rights to minorities in the short run as a matter of convenience, yet it seeks to assimilate diverse identities into a homogenous and monolith national identity within the nation-state in the long run. Unlike this, the accommodation framework leverages heterogeneity and multiple identities as enduring values.11 John McGarry, Brendan O'Leary and Richard Simeon, "Integration or Accommodation? The Enduring Debate in Conflict Regulation," in Sujit Choudhry (ed.), Constitutional Design for Divided Societies: Integration or Accommodation? (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008), 41–88.12 See Lars-Erik Cederman, Simon Hug, Andreas Schadel and Julia Wucherpfennig, "Territorial Autonomy in the Shadow of Conflict: Too Little, Too Late?" American Political Science Review 109, no. 2 (2015): 354–70, B. Petersohn, N. Behnke, and E.M. Rhode "Negotiating Territorial Change in Multinational State: Party Preferences, Negotiating Power and the Role of the Negotiation Mode," Publius: The Journal of Federalism 45, no.4 (2015): 626–52, Kham Khan Suan Hausing, "Autonomy and the Territorial Management of Ethnic Conflicts in Northeast India," Territory, Politics, Governance 10, no.1, 2022, 120-43, Timothy Sisk, Power Sharing and International Mediation in Ethnic Conflicts (Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press, 1996).13 Arend Lijphart, "The Wave of Power-Sharing Democracy," in Andrew Reynolds (ed.), The Architecture of Democracy: Constitutional Design, Conflict Management, and Democracy (New York: Oxford University Press, 2004): 37–54.14 McGarry and O'Leary, "Introduction," John McGarry and Brendan O'Leary, "Must Pluri-National Federations Fail?" Ethnopolitics 8, no. 1 (2009): 5–25.15 Sisk, Power Sharing.16 Ian Lustick, Dan Miodownik, and Roy J. Eidelson, "Secessionism in Multicultural States: Does Sharing Power Prevent or Encourage It? American Political Science Review 98, no. 2 (2004): 209–229.17 Joanne McEvoy (ed.), Power-Sharing in Deeply Divided Places (Philadelphia: UPenn Press, 2012).18 Robert Agranoff, "Autonomy, Devolution and Intergovernmental Relations," Regional and Federal Studies 14, no. 1 (2004.): 26–65.19 Nathalie Behnke and Sean Mueller, "The Purpose of Intergovernmental Councils: A Framework for Analysis and Comparison,' Regional and Federal Studies 27, no. 5 (2017): 507–27.20 Nicole Bolleyer and Evelyn Bytzek, "Government Congruence and Intergovernmental Relations in Federal Systems," Regional and Federal Studies 19, no. 3 (2009): 371–97.21 Yonatan T. Fessha, Karl Kossler and Francisco Palermo (eds.), Intergovernmental Relations in Deeply Divided Societies (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2022).22 Johanne Poirier, "Formal Mechanisms of Intergovernmental Relations in Belgium," Regional and Federal Studies 12, no. 3 (2002): 24–54.23 David Cameron and Richard Simeon, "Intergovernmental Relations in Canada: The Emergence of Collaborative Federalism," Publius 32, no. 2 (2002): 49–71.24 Wilfried Swenden and Simon Toubeau, "Mainstream Parties and Territorial Dynamics in the UK, Spain, and India," in Arthur Benz and Jorg Broschek (eds.), Federal Dynamics: Continuity, Change and the Varieties of Federalism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013): 249–73.25 Watts, Comparing Federal Systems.26 Deil S. Wright, "The States and Intergovernmental Relations," Publius 1, no. 2 (1972): 7–68.27 See Mahendra P. Singh, and Douglas V. Verney, "Challenges to India's Centralized Parliamentary Federalism," Publius 33, no. 4 (2003): 1–20; Wilfried Swenden, "Centre-State Bargaining and Territorial Accommodation: Evidence from India," Swiss Political Science Review 22, no. 4 (2016): 491–515.28 See Chanchal Kumar Sharma, "Reimagining Federalism in India: Exploring the Frontiers of Collaborative Federal Architecture," Asia-Pacific Social Science Review 15, no.1 (2015): 1–25, Rekha Saxena, Situating Federalism: Mechanisms of Intergovernmental Relations in Canada and India (New Delhi: Manohar, 2006), Rekha Saxena, "Intergovernmental Relations in India," in Meghna Sabharwal and Evan M. Berman (eds.), Public Administration in South Asia (London: CRC Press, 2013): 73–90.29 Balveer Arora, Beryl A. Radin, Cheryl Saunders and MD Rijhwani, "Theme 3: Interaction in a Federal System," in Conference Reader, 4th International Conference on Federalism, 5–7 November, 2007, New Delhi: 284–307.30 Swenden and Toubeau, "Mainstream Parties."31 See Balveer Arora, "Adapting Federalism to India: Multilevel and Asymmetrical Innovations," in Balveer Arora and Douglas V. Verney (eds). Multiple Identities in a Single State: Indian Federalism in Comparative Perspective (Delhi: Konark, 1995): 71–104, Louise Tillin, Remapping India: New States and their Political Origins (London: Hurst & Co, 2013), and Alfred Stepan, Juan J. Linz and Yogendra Yadav, Crafting State-nations: India and other Multinational Democracies (Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press, 2011).32 See Government of India (GoI), Constituent Assembly Debates: Official Report, Vol. 9 (July 30–August 18) (New Delhi: Lok Sabha Secretariat, 1949), Kham Khan Suan Hausing, "Asymmetric Federalism and the Question of Democratic Justice in Northeast India," India Review 13, no. 2 (2014): 87–111.33 Gurharpal Singh, "Resizing and Reshaping the State: India from Partition to the Present," in Brendan O'Leary, Ian S. Lustick and Thomas Callaghy (eds.), Right-sizing the State: The Politics of Moving Borders (London: Oxford University Press): 138–67.34 Bethany Lacina, Rival Claims: Ethnic Violence and Territorial Autonomy under Indian Federalism (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2017).35 Tillin, Remapping India.36 See Arora, "Adapting Federalism," and Alfred Stepan, "Federalism and Democracy: Beyond the US Model," Journal of Democracy 10, no. 4 (1999): 19–34.37 Tillin, Remapping India.38 Lacina, Rival Claims: 148–67.39 See Sumantra Bose, Kashmir: Roots of Conflict, Paths to Peace (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2003).40 Bose, Kashmir.41 Louise Tillin, "United in Diversity? Asymmetry in Indian Federalism," Publius 37, no.1 (2007): 45–67.42 See Bose, Kashmir, Rekha Chowdhary, Jammu and Kashmir 1990 and Beyond: Competitive Politics in the Shadow of Separatism (New Delhi: Sage, 2019).43 Yamini Aiyar and Louise Tillin, "'One Nation,' BJP, and the Future of Indian Federalism," India Review 19, no. 2 (2020): 117–35.44 The flowering of the bamboo proliferated breeding of rodents and led to extensive destruction of crops, which in turn caused famine.45 Hausing, "Asymmetric Federalism and the Question of Democratic Justice in Northeast India."46 Government of India, The Punjab Regional Committees Order, 1957(New Delhi: Ministry of Home Affairs, Notification, 4 November 1957).47 Kham Khan Suan Hausing, "Telangana and the Politics of State Formation in India: Recognition and Accommodation in a Multinational Federation," Regional and Federal Studies 28, no. 4 (2018): 447–68.48 Kham Khan Suan Hausing, "Self-Rule and Shared Rule," The Indian Express, New Delhi, 2020, op-ed.49 See Sharma, "Reimagining Federalism in India," Rekha Saxena, "Strengthening Federal Dialogue: Role of NDC and ISC," Contemporary India 1, no. 3 (2002): 51–64, Lawrence Saez, "The Sarkaria Commission and India's Struggle for Federalism," Contemporary South Asia 8, no.1 (1999): 41–63, Lawrence Saez, Federalism without a Centre: The Impact of Political and Economic Reform on India's Federal System (London: Sage, 2002).50 See Behnke and Mueller, "The Purpose of Intergovernmental Councils," Nicole Bolleyer, "Intergovernmental Arrangements in Spanish and Swiss Federalism: The Impact of Power-concentrating and Power-sharing Executives on Intergovernmental Institutionalization," Regional and Federal Studies 16, no. 4 (2006): 385–408, Bolleyer and Byztek, "Government Congruence," and Cameron and Simeon, "Intergovernmental Relations in Canada."51 Rajni Kothari, "The Congress 'System' in India," Asian Survey 4, no. 12 (1964): 1161–73.52 The four categories of states integrated into the Indian Union, viz., A, B, C, and D States had hitherto enjoyed variegated political status. While British Indian provinces (part A States) and the Chief Commissioner's (part C States) provinces enjoyed semi-sovereign status, the princely States (part B and part C States) had enjoyed either semi or sovereign status. Their distinctive political status required sensitive bargain and negotiation at the time of Indian independence.53 Article 1 of India's Constitution unambiguously declares: "India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States." The word "federalism" is conspicuous by its absence in the Indian Constitution.54 Kothari, "The Congress 'System'."55 Joseph E. Schwartzberg, "Factors in the Linguistic Reorganization of Indian States" in Asha Sarangi (ed.), Language and Politics in India (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2009): 139–82.56 See Harihar Bhattacharyya, "Federalism and Competing Nations in India," in Michael Burgess and John Pinder (eds). Multinational Federations (London: Routledge, 2007): 50–67, and Harihar Bhattacharyya, Kham Khan Suan Hausing and Jhumpa Mukherjee. "Indian Federalism at the Crossroads: Limits of the Territorial Management of Ethnic Conflict," India Review 16, no. 1 (2017): 149–78.57 See Swenden, "Centre-State Bargaining"58 Paul Brass, Language, Religion and Politics in North India (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1974).59 The titular King of Manipur, one of the princely states, who signed the Instrument of Accession under duress in October 1949 was, for example, given three hundred thousand Indian rupees per month from 1950 to 1971.60 Bose, Kashmir.61 Chowdhary, Jammu and Kashmir 1990 and Beyond.62 Kham Khan Suan Hausing, "Salvaging Autonomy in India's Northeast: Beyond the Sixth Schedule Way," in Bhagat Oinam and Dhiren A. Sadokpam (eds.). Northeast India: A Reader (New Delhi: Routledge, 2019): 187–98.63 GoI, Constituent Assembly Debates: 1009.64 See Sanjib Baruah, "Nationalizing Space: Cosmetic Federalism and the Politics of Development in Northeast India," Development and Change 34, no. 5 (2003): 915–39, and Hausing, "Asymmetric Federalism and the Question of Democratic Justice."65 On this see Rudolph and Rudolph, In Pursuit of Lakshmi, K.K. Kailash, "Regional Parties in the 16th Lok Sabha Elections: Who Survived and Why?" Economic and Political Weekly 49, no.39 (2014): 64–71, and Adam Ziegfeld, "Coalition and Party System Change: Explaining the Rise of Regional Political Parties in India," Comparative Politics 45, no. 1 (2012): 69–87.66 Kohli, "Centralization and Powerlessness."67 Bhagwan D. Dua, "Federalism or Patrimonialism: The Making and Unmaking of Chief Ministers in India," Asian Survey 25, no. 8 (1985): 793–804.68 Calculated by the author from data available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President%27s_rule#:~:text=In%20India%2C%20President's%20rule%20is,government%20rule%20in%20a%20state.69 Saxena, Situating Federalism: 277.70 On this see Ashok Chanda, "North Eastern Council: An Essentially Sound Plan," The Statesman, Calcutta, August 12, 1971.71 Indira Gandhi quoted by Arun Shourie while introducing the North-Eastern Council (Amendment) Bill, 2002 in the Lok Sabha on November 11, 2002. See full text of Lok Sabha Debates available online at: <http://164.100.47.132/LssNew/psearch/DebSubjectSearch-freetext.aspx>.72 Ibid., p.15.73 M.S. Prabhakar, "The North Eastern Council: Some Political Perspectives," Economic and Political Weekly 8, no. 40 (1973):1825.74 B.G. Verghese, "End the Isolation," Hindustan Times, New Delhi, May 2, 2002.75 Government of India, Commission on Centre-State Relations. 2 vols. (Chair: R.S. Sarkaria). (Delhi: Government of India Press, 1988).76 Ibid: vol 1: 543. Also see.77 See Yogendra Yadav and Suhas Palshikar, "From Hegemony to Convergence: Party System and Electoral Politics in the Indian States, 1952–2002," Journal of Indian School of Political Economy 15, nos. 1&2 (2003): 6–44.78 Ibid.79 See Chanchal Kumar Sharma, Sandra Destradi and Johannes Plagemann, "Partisan federalism and subnational governments' international engagements: Insights from India," Publius: The Journal of Federalism 50, no. 4 (2020): 566–92, Rudolph and Rudolph, "Iconisation of Chandrababu", Aseema Sinha, The Regional Roots of Developmental Politics in India: A Divided Leviathan (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2005), and Andrew Wyatt, "Paradiplomacy of India's Chief Ministers," India Review 16, no. 1 (2017): 106–24.80 Katharine Adeney, "Hindu Nationalists and Federal Structures in an Era of Regionalism," in Katharine Adeney and Lawrence Saez (eds.). Coalition Politics and Hindu Nationalism. (London: Routledge, 2005): 97–115.81 Balveer Arora and K.K. Kailash, "The New Party System: Federalized and Binodal," in Ajay Mehra (ed.). Party System in India: Emerging Trajectories (New Delhi: Lancer, 2012): 235–61.82 See Aiyar and Tillin, "'One Nation,' BJP, and the Future of Indian Federalism," Thomas Blom Hansen, The Saffron Wave: Democracy and Hindu Nationalism in Modern India. (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1999), and Suhas Palshikar, "Majoritarian Middle Ground?" Economic and Political Weekly 39, no. 51 (2004): 5426–30.83 Katharine Adeney and Harihar Bhattacharyya, "Current Challenges to Multinational Federalism in India," Regional and Federal Studies 28, no. 4 (2018): 409–25.84 On this see Asha Sarangi and Sudha Pai (eds). Interrogating Reorganisation of States: Culture, Identity and Politics in India (New Delhi: Routledge, 2011), Tillin, Remapping India, Hausing, "Telangana and the Politics of State Formation in India."85 Hansen, The Saffron Wave: 221.86 See GoI, National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (Chair: M. N. Venkatachaliah) (New Delhi: GoI Press, 2002), 2 vols; GoI, Commission on Centre-State Relations, 7 vols (Chair: M.M. Punchhi)(Delhi: Government of India Press: 2010).87 GoI, Commission on Centre-State Relations, vol. 2: 50–52.88 GoI, Commission on Centre-State Relations, vol. 2: 167–9.89 Bhattacharyya et al., "Indian Federalism at the Crossroads."90 Bethany Lacina, "India's Stabilizing Segment States," Ethnopolitics 13, no.1 (2014): 13–27.91 See Hausing, "Telangana and the Politics of State Formation in India."92 Arjan H. Schakel, Schakel, Chanchal Kumar Sharma and Wilfried Swenden, "India After the 2014 General Elections: BJP Dominance and the Crisis of the Third Party System," Regional and Federal Studies 29, no. 3 (2019): 329–54.93 Aiyar and Tillin, "'One Nation,' BJP, and the Future of Indian Federalism": 121.94 Yamini Aiyar and Neelanjan Sircar, "Understanding the Decline of Regional Party Power in the 2019 National Election and Beyond," Contemporary South Asia 28, no. 2 (2020): 209–22.95 See Modi's blog post here: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/narendra-modis-blog/co-operative-not-coercive-federalism-for-strong-republic/.96 GoI, Cabinet Secretariat Resolution no. 511/2/1/2015-Cab 1 January 2015 (New Delhi: Government of India Press, 2015).97 Ibid.98 Aiyar and Tillin, "'One Nation,' BJP, and the Future of Indian Federalism": 127.99 Over and above these nine CMs, it also includes as its member the Lt. Governor of UT of Andaman and Nicobar Islands.100 GoI, Report of the Sub-group of Chief Ministers on Rationalisation of Centrally Sponsored Schemes. (New Delhi: NITI Aayog, 2015).101 Aiyar and Tillin, "'One Nation,' BJP, and the Future of Indian Federalism:"129.102 Y.V. Reddy and G.R. Reddy, Indian Fiscal Federalism (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2019): 166–75.103 A.G. Noorani, "Kashmir: Murder of Insaniyat,' Frontline, August 30, 2019. Accessed online: https://frontline.thehindu.com/cover-story/article29049528.ece.104 Hausing, "Self-rule and Shared Rule."105 Ibid.Additional informationFundingThis article was funded by the Indian Council of Social Science Research under its IMPRESS project titled, "Asymmetric Autonomy and the Politics of Accommodation in Northeast India", 2019-21 (File no. P1702/108/2018/19/ICSSR).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kham Khan Suan Hausing (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: