Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article addresses the question of whether the soul has substantial reality from the perspective of Jungian psychology and contemporary physics. It is a response to Daniel Anderson’s article, “The Soul’s Logical Life and Jungian Schisms.” Where psychology and physics have progressed the farthest into the unknown dimensions of psyche and matter, they have both conjectured that there is a symbol in the truth of things. I explore this idea as it appears in Romanticism, Jungian psychology, and physics, particularly in Jung’s correspondence with Wolfgang Pauli. My conclusion is that the unconscious psyche is not exclusively methodological but also has substantial reality identical to the unknown dimension of the microphysical world. Both the unknown dimensions of psyche and matter are visible and comprehensible to us only through symbols. The first-ever direct observation of the wave function of a hydrogen atom in 2013 is used as an example.On the one hand, we have the living impression of pneumatic Christendom, that is, the Christian world view, while on the other hand, we have scientific materialism. And that is the well-known conflict between faith and knowledge which we are in. And now the question here is what is the unconscious doing now? (Jung, as cited in Schweizer & Schweizer-Vüllers, 2016 Schweizer, A., & Schweizer-Vüllers, R. (2016). Stone by stone: Reflections on the psychology of C. G. Jung. Daimon Verlag. [Google Scholar], p. 179)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomas Elsner (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: